Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the representation and calculation of atomic sizes for all elements in the periodic table. Participants explore various sources for atomic radius charts, the methods used to derive these values, and the implications of atomic size in relation to electronic structure and bonding.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
Main Points Raised
- One participant seeks a comprehensive chart of atomic sizes, noting that existing atomic radius charts are based on bonded atoms and may not reflect actual atomic sizes.
- Several participants share links to resources, particularly from webelements, that provide representations of atomic sizes.
- There is a discussion about the absence of representations for noble gases, attributed to their inertness and difficulty in determining covalent radii.
- Some participants question the relative sizes of diatomic molecules like H2 compared to other atoms, with one noting that the He atom is smaller than the H atom.
- Participants discuss the trend of atomic radii decreasing as electronic orbitals fill, with one suggesting that this trend contradicts intuition and asking for explanations.
- There are inquiries about the accuracy of the atomic radius values presented, with one participant expressing concern over the rounding of values and the methods used to derive them.
- One participant speculates on the representation of hydrogen in charts, questioning whether it is depicted as a point due to its size or as a representation of a hydrogen ion.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express various viewpoints regarding the accuracy and representation of atomic sizes, with no consensus reached on the most accurate method for determining these values. The discussion includes both agreement on certain trends and ongoing questions about specific details.
Contextual Notes
Participants note that atomic sizes are derived from bond lengths, which may not accurately represent the physical size of atoms. The discussion highlights the variability in atomic radius values based on different derivation methods, and the implications of electronic structure on atomic size are also considered.