Why is mercury a liquid even though its atoms are closely packed

AI Thread Summary
Mercury remains a liquid despite its closely packed atoms due to the nature of its outer electrons, which are strongly bonded and not free to form solid structures. This strong bonding results in a softer metal that requires less energy to break the bonds, distinguishing it from other metals. In contrast, water ice is less dense than liquid water because of its unique hexagonal lattice structure, which creates open spaces. The discussion also highlights that noble gases are gaseous due to their full outer electron shells, preventing bonding. Overall, the state of a substance is determined by its atomic structure and bonding characteristics.
jablonsky27
Messages
74
Reaction score
0
the density of ice(solid) is less than that of water(liquid) and density of mercury(liquid) is more than that of many solids.
thinking about it, it seemed natural to me that the more closely are the atoms or molecules packed the greater will be their density. but on packing them closely, isn't the state also going to be more solid-like?
so what determines a substances density and what determines its state?
what keeps the H20 molecules in place in ice but not as tightly packed as in liquid water so that its density is reduced? and why is mercury a liquid even though its atoms are (obviously?) closely packed?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Water is anomalous in it's solid state being less dense than liquid.
It depends on the crystal structure which depends on the bond angle and chemical nature of the bonds.

Mercury is a liquid because it's outer electrons are very strongly bonded.
Strongly attatched outer electrons aren't free to bond with other atoms and so the metal is softer because it takes less energy to break the bonds. Mercury is the ultimate example of this.
Gold has a half full outer shell and so also has relatively weak bonds to other atoms and is a soft metal.
 
Last edited:
Ya, as was mentioned, water ice is an anomaly and the reason is because it forms a hexagonal lattice structure like the one shown here:

http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/ATG/images/ice1h.gif

Therefore, if you look at the lattice structure you'll see that there is a lot of open space and thus it has a lower density. However, it is not the general case that a molecule will form such an open spacious lattice
 
thanks mgb_phys and maverick_starstrider. i understand that water-ice is an anomaly.

Mercury is a liquid because it's outer electrons are very strongly bonded.
Strongly attatched outer electrons aren't free to bond with other atoms and so the metal is softer because it takes less energy to break the bonds. Mercury is the ultimate example of this.
Gold has a half full outer shell and so also has relatively weak bonds to other atoms and is a soft metal.

What are the outer electrons in mercury strongly bonded to? Do you mean that outer electrons(valence electrons right?) are not easily available to participate in reactions? In mercury, which is a metal, the outer electrons are 'free' in a sense to conduct electricity right?

Is that also why all the 'stable' elements like He, Ne, Ar etc are gases?
 
The outer electrons - like all the others are strongly attracted to the nucleus, in mercury the large mass and charge of the nucleus mean the outer valence electrons are very strongly held - so aren't available to do the nomal free electron sea metal thing. (although they must have some freedom or mercury wouldn't be shiny!)

http://antoine.frostburg.edu/chem/senese/101/periodic/faq/why-is-mercury-liquid.shtml

The noble gases are gases because theie outer shells are completely full and so there are no free electrons to bond with other atoms of the same species. If the atoms are all on their own they are pretty much forced to be a gas. Interestingly mercury gas is single atoms like a noble gas.
 
So I know that electrons are fundamental, there's no 'material' that makes them up, it's like talking about a colour itself rather than a car or a flower. Now protons and neutrons and quarks and whatever other stuff is there fundamentally, I want someone to kind of teach me these, I have a lot of questions that books might not give the answer in the way I understand. Thanks
Back
Top