Comparing Gas Stoichiometry Approaches: Which One is Correct?

  • Thread starter Thread starter supernova1203
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Gas Stoichiometry
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on two approaches to solving gas stoichiometry problems using the ideal gas law, PV=nRT. The first approach involves calculating the volume using molar volume for SATP, while the second approach uses the given volume directly. Participants emphasize the importance of unit consistency, noting that incorrect unit handling can lead to nonsensical results. Clarification is sought on whether the calculated mass of helium is in grams or kilograms, highlighting the need for attention to units in calculations. Ultimately, the correct approach hinges on ensuring that all units are properly accounted for in the final solution.
supernova1203
Messages
209
Reaction score
0
So iv solved all these problems, id just like someone to take a look at them and see which approach is right.

The question is in the attachment.

first approach is i use molar volume for SATP which is 24.76L and multiply 65L with it
and i get 1609.4L then i use this in the universal gas forumla(i think that's what its called)

PV=nRT

(100)(1609.4) = n(8.31)(298)

(100)(1609.4)/(8.31)(298) = n


second approach i use is where i just use the 65L of volume as is and put it in the equation, since they both are volumes, which one is the right way?

PV=nRT

(100)(65)=n(8.31)(298)
(100)(65)/(8.31)(298) = n

which approach is correct?
 

Attachments

  • Lesson 20 question for PF.jpg
    Lesson 20 question for PF.jpg
    3.8 KB · Views: 466
Physics news on Phys.org
Also another question here, in a 2nd attachment

v=7.5 L

t=25C or 298K

P=100Kpa

PV=nRT

(100)(7.5)=n(8.31)(298)

750/(8.31)(298) =n

750/2476.38 =nHe

0.302=nHe (helium)

mass = n X molar mass

=(0.302)(4)

=1.208

Is this in grams or Kg? the mass of helium?
 

Attachments

  • Lesson 20 question for PF2.jpg
    Lesson 20 question for PF2.jpg
    3.4 KB · Views: 468
supernova1203 said:
first approach is i use molar volume for SATP which is 24.76L and multiply 65L with it and i get 1609.4L

No, you don't get 1609L, you get 1609L2 - whatever it means. Watch your units and you will see when your approach doesn't make sense.
 
supernova1203 said:
Is this in grams or Kg? the mass of helium?

Again, if you were watching your units answer would be obvious.

What are units of molar mass?
 
Borek said:
Again, if you were watching your units answer would be obvious.

What are units of molar mass?

g/mol?
 
Last edited:
Borek said:
No, you don't get 1609L, you get 1609L2 - whatever it means. Watch your units and you will see when your approach doesn't make sense.

so the first approach is what will get the correct solution?
 
supernova1203 said:
g/mol?

You havew to guess, you can't check?

supernova1203 said:
so the first approach is what will get the correct solution?

Only if the units make sense. Check if they do. What units should the final answer be in? What units your final answer has?
 
Last edited:
i did check but i wasnt sure, hence the question mark.
 
Back
Top