Another convergent and divergent

tnutty

1. Homework Statement
Determine whether the series is convergent or divergent.
$$\sum$$ n5 / (n6 + 1)

Related Calculus and Beyond Homework Help News on Phys.org

lanedance

Homework Helper
hi tnutty - any ideas?
maybe a comparison test...

tnutty

Yes I was thinking of the comparison test, but thats next chapter. in this chpt, its all about integral test. i am not sure how to solve this with integral test, but can you check out the comparison test that follows ?

Comparison test ;

n^5 / (n^6+1) <= n^5 / n^6 = 1/n and from definition we know that 1/(n^p)
converges if n > 1 and diverges if n< 1. So in this case it diverges since n = 1.

Any ideas solving this by integral test?

rwisz

The comparison test does show divergence that's right.

For the integral test however, since the numerator contains $$n^5$$ and the derivative of the denominator is $$6n^5$$ then you should be able to tell that u-substitution will work like a charm here...

Hint: du/u = ln u.

And for the setup of the improper integral, try looking at the previous thread where I helped you, at the bottom of my last post.

rwisz

And for the setup of the improper integral, try looking at the previous thread where I helped you, at the bottom of my last post. And because I'm going to bed right now and you seem like you really do need some brushing up on your series, here's the work for it step-by-step!

$${\lim }\limits_{b \to \infty } \int_1^b \frac{n^5}{n^6+1}dn$$ Determine your u substitution.

$$u=n^6+1, du=6n^5$$ Rewrite the integral.

$${\lim }\limits_{b \to \infty } \frac{1}{6} \int_1^b \frac{du}{u}$$ Evaluate the integral.

$${\lim}\limits_{b \to \infty } ln(6b^6+1)-ln(6^6+1)$$ Substitute in for $$b$$

$$\infty - ln(6^6+1) = \infty$$

Infinity minus a number = Infinity.

Hence by the Integral Test the series diverges!

Mark44

Mentor
Yes I was thinking of the comparison test, but thats next chapter. in this chpt, its all about integral test. i am not sure how to solve this with integral test, but can you check out the comparison test that follows ?

Comparison test ;

n^5 / (n^6+1) <= n^5 / n^6 = 1/n and from definition we know that 1/(n^p)
converges if n > 1 and diverges if n< 1. So in this case it diverges since n = 1.
?
No, you can't conclude from this comparison that the series diverges. For the comparison test to show that a series diverges, the terms have to be larger than those of a divergent series. Here you show that they are smaller than those of $\sum 1/n$.

Mark44

Mentor
The comparison test does show divergence that's right.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but no it does not. Take a look at the comparison test and what it says about divergent series and what it says about convergent series. They are different.
For the integral test however, since the numerator contains $$n^5$$ and the derivative of the denominator is $$6n^5$$ then you should be able to tell that u-substitution will work like a charm here...

Hint: du/u = ln u.

And for the setup of the improper integral, try looking at the previous thread where I helped you, at the bottom of my last post.

lanedance

Homework Helper
as Mark mentioned out the comparison test points out that if

$$b_n > a_n$$ for all n>N then if an diverges so does bn
so your pevious example doesn't work...

but to get this condition you could notice

$$\frac{n^5}{n^6 + 1} > \frac{1}{2n}$$ which is true $$\forall n >1$$

or
$$\frac{n^5}{n^6 + 1} > \frac{n^5}{n^6 + n^5} = \frac{1}{n+1}$$ which is true $$\forall n >1$$ and cleary diverges...

clearly

rwisz

Sorry to burst your bubble, but no it does not. Take a look at the comparison test and what it says about divergent series and what it says about convergent series. They are different.
Ah good catch! I was not paying close enough attention, I apologize. But I did prove divergence by the Integral test... so I get some slack right? :)

No but in all seriousness I do apologize, for lack of a better phrase, my bad!

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving