Calculus Any suggestions for good beginner calculus textbooks.

AI Thread Summary
A user seeks recommendations for a calculus textbook suitable for beginners. "Calculus Made Easy" by Silvanus P. Thompson is suggested, but there is debate over the effectiveness of other popular texts like James Stewart's, which some consider too basic. Alternatives such as Apostol and Thomas' "Calculus With Analytical Geometry" are recommended, with Apostol noted as challenging for beginners unless they have strong foundational knowledge. The discussion emphasizes the importance of understanding prior mathematics, including algebra and trigonometry, to successfully learn calculus. Additionally, the user expresses a desire to apply calculus to physics, aiming to align their knowledge with British educational standards. The conversation touches on the accessibility of mathematical texts in different languages, with mentions of resources in Spanish and German.
TheAnt
Messages
19
Reaction score
1
Hi, i am looking for a good textbook for someone who knows nothing about calculus.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
TheAnt said:
Hi, i am looking for a good textbook for someone who knows nothing about calculus.
Calculus Made Easy by Silvanus P. Thompson
 
TheAnt said:
Hi, i am looking for a good textbook for someone who knows nothing about calculus.

You need to tell us what you do know and what your longterm goals are.
 
Well, I don't know, but people here in Brazil at UFRJ uses James Stewart.
 
Yeah, Stewart is about the worst book you can get for calculus, whatever your goals are.
 
Really? I've heard that it's too basic, now that I remembered
I already know, If you want to know calculus, try Apostol, but remember, you have to know all the subjects of Elementary School II and the High School.
 
I would suggest Thomas: Calculus With Analytical Geometry 3rd ed, and Serge Lang's Calculus book. Buy both, they are cheap enough.
Apostol is a great book. However, I would not recommended it to a beginner, unless the student is extremely bright or someone can help them.
 
Hum... I went to look for, and I found this, I did not go out of the still pre-calculus, now that I went to see my books and have them.

oqvrdi.jpg
 
You are able to read spanish fluently?

Sorry, that appears to be Italian or French. lol I am fluent in both Spanish and English.
 
  • #10
MidgetDwarf said:
You are able to read spanish fluently?

You know, reading mathematical texts is very different from usual texts. I am completely certain I can't say a single sentence in spanish. However, I am able to read spanish mathematical texts decently. Given some time and a dictionary, it's pretty easy to fluently read a foreign math book!
 
  • #11
This is not Spanish, it's Portuguese, I'm native Portuguese speaker (from Brazil).
 
  • #12
micromass said:
You know, reading mathematical texts is very different from usual texts. I am completely certain I can't say a single sentence in spanish. However, I am able to read spanish mathematical texts decently. Given some time and a dictionary, it's pretty easy to fluently read a foreign math book!

I may try that Differential Equations book by Kamke then. It is German, and I always see it referenced in other books.
 
  • #13
Joseph Richard said:
This is not Spanish, it's Portuguese, I'm native Portuguese speaker (from Brazil).

Oh ok, I asked because I know of a very good Calculus book in Spanish. There is also a series of good physics book that are affordable in Spanish, but not English.
 
  • #14
micromass said:
You need to tell us what you do know and what your longterm goals are.
I am in the french system but i think i have igcse/as level mathematics. My goal is simply to apply calculus to physics as i was told it was needed to move on.
 
  • #15
TheAnt said:
I am in the french system but i think i have igcse/as level mathematics. My goal is simply to apply calculus to physics as i was told it was needed to move on.

Sorry, but this tells us nothing. I know high school students who can't solve a simple arithmetic problem, and I know of some who are doing general relativity. So you'll need to be more specific.

I understand that you want to be a physicist? Or an engineer? Why is it that you want to learn physics?
 
  • #16
micromass said:
Sorry, but this tells us nothing. I know high school students who can't solve a simple arithmetic problem, and I know of some who are doing general relativity. So you'll need to be more specific.

I understand that you want to be a physicist? Or an engineer? Why is it that you want to learn physics?
Sorry for the lack of precision in my earlier reply. What i want for the moment is just a basic knowledge of calculus as it is tackled much later and in less depth in France than in other countries (eg. England). The main goal is to get on par with the British level once I reach university. As for my current level, it is pretty good in the french system (top marks) but this is without counting the knowledge I lack.
 
  • #17
TheAnt said:
Sorry for the lack of precision in my earlier reply. What i want for the moment is just a basic knowledge of calculus as it is tackled much later and in less depth in France than in other countries (eg. England). The main goal is to get on par with the British level once I reach university. As for my current level, it is pretty good in the french system (top marks) but this is without counting the knowledge I lack.

What Micromass is asking you, is what mathematics do you know. Ie, do you know algebra, geometry,trig etc. At what level do you know these topics? Ie, trigonometry from a general run of of the mill trig book, or maybe Gelfand, or even better, Loney?
 

Similar threads

Back
Top