Apply Fermat's principle to a Concave mirror

1 reply · 3K views · last reply
KT KIM
Messages
24
Reaction score
0
I am now taking optics class at my school. Fermat principle can be applied on mirror of course.
Equation δS = δ ∫ from A to B of n ds = 0, showing the variation of the optical path integral set to zero between points A and B.

Then what about Concave mirror? According to the calculus of variation. the optimized path(actual path of the light) should be the shortest path. but in the concave mirror case, it goes through the longest path.
Diagram of a concave mirror M with points a and b above it and reflection points A, B, C along the x-axis, plus a graph of OPL against x peaking at B.

Like above.

How can I apply Fermat's principle on concave mirror?
 
KT KIM said:
I am now taking optics class at my school. Fermat principle can be applied on mirror of course.
Equation: delta S = delta of the integral from A to B of n ds, equal to 0.

Then what about Concave mirror? According to the calculus of variation. the optimized path(actual path of the light) should be the shortest path. but in the concave mirror case, it goes through the longest path.
Diagram titled Maximum OPL, a concave mirror: points a and b above a curved mirror M with reflection points A, B and C on the x-axis, with a graph of OPL against x peaking at B.

Like above.

How can I apply Fermat's principle on concave mirror?

With variational principles, the path is not the absolute minimum (or maximum) it is only a local extremum. What this means is the following: If you shift the path slightly to the dotted path shown in the figure below, by shifting the location where the light ray hits the mirror by [itex]\Delta x[/itex], then the change in the path length will be of order [itex](\Delta x)^2[/itex]. That's a statement about the limit as [itex]\Delta x \rightarrow 0[/itex]. Fermat's principle doesn't say anything about paths that are very different from the given path, it only applies to infinitesimally different paths.

Diagram of a light ray from point a reflecting off a concave mirror M at point B to point b; a dashed alternative path hits the mirror at a nearby point, offset by a small distance labelled Δx along the x-axis.