Battery that will run a dc motor

AI Thread Summary
Using a battery to run a DC motor that powers a three-phase AC generator is theoretically possible, but impractical due to energy losses. While one phase of the generator can recharge the battery, it cannot do so faster than the battery is drained, violating the conservation of energy. The system will ultimately lead to a net energy loss, preventing perpetual motion. Discussions on perpetual motion machines are not entertained in this forum, as they are considered unfeasible. The thread was subsequently closed due to repeated inquiries on the same topic.
Mujahid
Messages
6
Reaction score
0
hi i am new to this forum. i want to use a battery that will run a dc motor, dc motor will run three phase ac generator through mechanical coupling and the three phase ac generator will produce out put, now two phases of the ac generator will b utlilized by the load and 1 phase will recharge the battery. my question is wheather its possible or not?
 
Physics news on Phys.org


yes is possible. But you will need to separately and independently recharge the battery periodically since friction and electrical losses cannot be overcome.
In other words its impractical.

Try here for practical insights: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_car
 


sir you mean its theoratically possible but practically impossible?
 


no I mean it can be done but accomplishes nothing...except temporarily until the battery runs down...trying to recharge the battery from the output consumes more energy than it produces...
 


Even theoretically with 100% efficiency and no losses anywhere in the system the 1 phase used for recharging cannot recharge the battery faster than it is being drained if there is a load on the other 2 phases.

It is certainly possible to build the device you describe, but it won't recharge the battery as fast as it is drained.
 


No, it is not possible. Violates conservation of energy.
 


how sir?
 


is there any alternative?
 


Mujahid said:
hi i am new to this forum. i want to use a battery that will run a dc motor, dc motor will run three phase ac generator through mechanical coupling and the three phase ac generator will produce out put, now two phases of the ac generator will b utlilized by the load and 1 phase will recharge the battery. my question is wheather its possible or not?

If you use part of the converted a/c power to charge the battery there will still be a net loss of energy (due to irreversibilities in the conversion process). So strictly speaking you can "charge" the battery, but you can't fully recharge it such that it violates the conservation of energy.

In other words you cannot create a perpetual motion machine. The battery will eventually drain completely.

CS
 
  • #10


Yes, charge it with an external power source.
 
  • #11


This is the third post of this exact topic by the same user...

Do not multipost...

CS
 
  • #12


can we eliminate all the losses?
 
  • #13


is there any research on practical perpetual motion machine?
 
  • #14


Mujahid said:
is there any research on practical perpetual motion machine?

We do not discuss perpetual motion machines here on the PF because it is a waste of time. Please re-read the Rules link at the top of the page.

Thread closed.
 
Back
Top