Calculate P(|Xn| > .08), n = 16

  • Thread starter Thread starter Addez123
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the probability P(|Xn| > .08) for n = 16, where Xn is normally distributed with a mean of 0.1 and a standard deviation of 2. The initial calculation incorrectly assumes symmetry about the mean, leading to an erroneous probability result. The correct approach involves recognizing that the limits are not symmetrical around the mean, requiring the use of φ(-.09) and φ(-.01) instead of just doubling φ(-.09). After correcting the calculation, the accurate probability aligns with the book's answer of 0.968.
Addez123
Messages
199
Reaction score
21
Homework Statement
X1, X2.. are independend, equally distributed measuring errors with expected value .1 and standard deviation 8.
Xn = (X1 + X2 + ... + Xn) / n
Calculate P(|Xn| > .08) for n = 16
Relevant Equations
$$X + Y = N(u_x + u_y, \sqrt{\sigma_x^2 + \sigma_y^2}$$
Here's how I tried to solve it.
$$Xn = N(.1 * n, \sigma*\sqrt{n}) / n = N(.1, 8 / \sqrt{16}) = N(.1, 2)$$
$$P(|Xn| > .08) = 1 - P(-.08 < x < .08) = $$
$$1 - (1 - 2P(x < -.08)) = 2P(x < -.08) =$$
$$2*\phi(\frac {-.08 - .1}{2}) = 2\phi(-.09) =$$
$$2 * (1 - \phi(.09)) = 2 * (1 - .5358) = .9284$$

Answer in my book says .968, its too much to be a rounding error.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Is P(x<-.08) + P(x>.08) = 2P(x<-.08) when μ≠0?
 
mjc123 said:
Is P(x<-.08) + P(x>.08) = 2P(x<-.08) when μ≠0?
It's not. But when I calculate the probability I convert it to N(0, 1) distribution:
$$2*\phi(\frac {-.08 - .1}{2}) $$
 
But that is not right. Do you see why? Your limits are not symmetrical about the mean.
 
When working with P(x.. I assume the u = 0.
When I later calculate P I use standard normal distribution doing:
$$2*\phi(\frac {-.08 - .1}{2}) $$
instead of just
$$2*\phi(-.08) $$

I don't see how that's wrong?
 
The limits are -.08 and +.08. The mean is 0.1. Translated into a standard normal distribution, you are looking at the range -.09 to -.01. The probability is not 2φ(-.09). It is φ(-.09) + 1-φ(-.01).
 
  • Informative
Likes Addez123
Aha, that was the issue. Re did it and now I get the correct answer, thanks!
 
Back
Top