Calculating Work and Energy in a Box on a Floor: A Quick Problem

  • Thread starter Thread starter ThatDude
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Energy Work
AI Thread Summary
A person pushes a box with a 250 N force over 12.75 m, resulting in 3187.5 Joules of work done on the box. The work done by friction is calculated as -3187.5 Joules, indicating that it opposes the motion. The total work done is zero, as the positive work from the person is canceled out by the negative work from friction. There is a discussion about whether the total work should be considered zero, given that friction generates heat in the system. Ultimately, the calculations were confirmed to be correct, and the initial confusion was resolved.
ThatDude
Messages
33
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



A person is pushing a box on a floor with a 250 N force. The box is moving at a constant speed over 12.75 m.

(a) What quantity of work does the person do on the box?
(b) What quantity of word does friction do?
(c) What is the total work done?

2. The attempt at a solution

(a) W = F * d * cosx = (250 N)(12.75 m)(cos0) = 3187.5 Joules

(b) W = F * d * cosx = (250 N)(12.75 m)(cos180) = -3187.5 Joules

(c) Total work = Wperson + Wfriction = 3187.5 J + (-3187.5 J) = 0
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Do you have a question?
Your working seems correct.(I don't have my calculator at the moment)
 
I was wondering if my process for (c) was correct.
 
ThatDude said:
I was wondering if my process for (c) was correct.
Probably not correct, but now I'm unsure of whether there is a strict convention to adhere to on the topic of friction. Were I to answer this as a test, I would have given the one identical answer to all 3 parts.

I wouldn't like to say zero total work has been done, because I can see that heat has been added to the system as a result of the friction. (So I'm tipping that maybe we say the work done by friction is zero.)

We'd best wait on to see what others say.
 
Last edited:
ThatDude said:

Homework Statement



A person is pushing a box on a floor with a 250 N force. The box is moving at a constant speed over 12.75 m.

(a) What quantity of work does the person do on the box?
(b) What quantity of word does friction do?
(c) What is the total work done?

(b) is a negative number.
(c) = (a) + (b)
 
I can see why work done by friction is considered negative. W=F.s, so when motion is in a direction opposite to that of F then one of the terms will have a negative sign. For the block, though, where movement is in the same direction as F then their product will be positive, and positive work is done. Thanks rude man.
 
That means all the answers in the OP are correct
 
adjacent said:
That means all the answers in the OP are correct

EDIT: sorry, hadn't noticed the OP's answers changed. Or maybe I misread them.

In any case, yes, they are now correct if he did the math correctly.
 
Last edited:
The confusion was mine. OP was correct from the start.
 
Back
Top