scientist91
- 133
- 0
Thank you.
The discussion revolves around the behavior of electrons in atomic orbitals, specifically addressing whether electrons can transition between energy states without radiating energy, and the effects of light on electrons. The scope includes conceptual understanding of atomic structure and photon interactions.
Participants generally disagree on the clarity of the original question and the implications of light's interaction with electrons. Multiple competing views remain regarding the specifics of electron transitions and the effects of light.
There are limitations in the discussion regarding the assumptions made about electron behavior and the definitions of terms used, which may affect the clarity of the conversation.
This discussion may be useful for individuals interested in atomic physics, photon interactions, and the conceptual challenges of communicating complex scientific ideas.
G01 said:...
Scientist, the questions you post on these forums are way too vague, and sometimes worded incorrectly. You seem to be trying to learn a lot about Physics, which is great, but you aren't going to learn physics by asking vague random questions on this forum. The best you can hope from this forum is to supplement your learning.
Please buy a book, start from the basics, and then you will be able to ask more detailed, useful questions, using the right terminology, and we will be able to help you all the better.
I know that the light can excite them and push out of the orbitals, but after exciting them, can the light push them in one correct direction?ice109 said:maybe he means can the electron go from excited to ground state without radiating energy? or maybe the reverse?![]()
scientist91 said:In my book, there is not texts or paragraphs about atomic particles like electrons ;)
scientist91 said:In my book, there is not texts or paragraphs about atomic particles like electrons ;)
scientist91 said:can the light push the electrons ?
like mechanical push?
like pushing some object in right direction?
like pushing some objects with mass (let's say I am pushing ball in certain direction, right?)?ice109 said:yes light can push things and it can push electrons in free space but it doesn't push electrons in orbitals.
scientist91 said:like pushing some objects with mass (let's say I am pushing ball in certain direction, right?)?
like pushing some objects with mass (let's say I am pushing ball in certain direction, right?)?ice109 said:yes light can push things and it can push electrons in free space but it doesn't push electrons in orbitals.
scientist91 said:like pushing some objects with mass (let's say I am pushing ball in certain direction, right?)?
Yes it have mass, but answer me on my questionice109 said:an electron has mass doesn't it![]()
scientist91 said:Yes it have mass, but answer me on my question
like pushing some objects (let's say I am pushing ball in certain direction, right?)?
In free space, right? Can they be excited in free space by the light?cepheid said:Hey, man, you're asking a simple Yes/No question, and the answer has already been given to you (yes) along with a resource to find further information on the topic (ZapperZ's suggestion to read up on the Compton effect).