Solving a Length of Curve with 0<t<2π: Find the Answer

  • Thread starter Thread starter manenbu
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Curve Length
manenbu
Messages
101
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Find the length of the curve:
x = 2a cos t - a cos 2t
y = 2a sin t - a sin 2t

0<t<2π

Homework Equations



L = \int_{C} dl

The Attempt at a Solution



Well, after a lot of manipulating and using trig identities, I get this:

L= 4a \int_{0}^{2\pi} \sin{t} dt
When I solve, I get 0.
But - if I change the range to be not 0<t<2π but 0<t<π, and then multiply by 2 - I get 16a as the answer, which is correct.
My question is why? I can see why it is like that "numerically" but not "philosophically".
How do I identify a situation where I need to do it, without looking at the answers, next time?
And was I doing everything correct? Or maybe it just turned out to be the correct answer by accident?
Thanks!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Likely you have a mistake somewhere. I get:

ds = \sqrt{x&#039;(t)^2 +y&#039;(t)^2}\ dt = 2\sqrt2 a \sqrt{1 - cos(t)}\ dt

which gives the correct answer.
 
I had that too.
But:
2\sqrt2 a \sqrt{1 - cos(t)}\ dt = 2\sqrt2 a \sqrt{2 sin^2(\frac{t}{2}} dt = 4a sin(\frac{t}{2})

Assuming that the trig identity is correct, what went wrong here?
The latter form is much easier to integrate.
 
oh. in the original integral I missed the \frac{t}{2}.
nevermind, problem solved.
 
Back
Top