Engineering Circuit Analysis Homework Help: Parts A & C

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving parts A and C of a circuit analysis homework problem. For part A, the user is trying to determine if the input voltage (Vin) equals 4V, given that Va is 4V, and seeks clarification on calculating I1 and Vc using Ohm's law. In part C, the user struggles with the behavior of an ideal opamp and the voltage across R1, ultimately confirming that the voltage drop across the resistor is 2V, leading to a current of 2mA. The conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding opamp characteristics and applying Ohm's law over nodal analysis for this specific problem. Overall, the user expresses gratitude for the assistance and indicates potential for further questions.
KTiaam
Messages
53
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


4gL67ax.png

Need help on part a.
and c.

The Attempt at a Solution


  • Part A
Since Va = 4V then pin 2 and 3 also have 4v. Would that mean that Vin is = 4v as well?
Im just confused how to find I1.
Also I am not sure how to find Vc.
  • Part C
As for part c, I am having trouble with it entirely.

Any help is appreciated!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
KTiaam said:
Since Va = 4V then pin 2 and 3 also have 4v. Would that mean that Vin is = 4v as well?
Well, yes, but you'll have to argue that based on the characteristics of an opamp with negative feedback. If you think in terms of the two golden rules of ideal opamp analysis..

KTiaam said:
Im just confused how to find I1.
You know what the voltage is across R1. What about Ohm's law?

KTiaam said:
As for part c, I am having trouble with it entirely.
Consider again the behavior of an ideal opamp with the feedback shown. It desperately wants to turn on that BJT hard, so it can reduce the voltage across its terminals to zero, but that really only requires the BJT to just barely move out of its cutoff region. You usually assume something about VBE then.
 
Last edited:
milesyoung said:
You know what the voltage is across R1. What about Ohm's law?

The thing that threw me off, is what voltage to use with r1,
But based off of the orientation of the current source, I use Vb?
 
KTiaam said:
The thing that threw me off, is what voltage to use with r1,
But based off of the orientation of the current source, I use Vb?
The voltage (with respect to ground) at Vb is 6 V, and you drop down to 4 V as you cross the resistor to Va.

Does that help?
 
milesyoung said:
The voltage (with respect to ground) at Vb is 6 V, and you drop down to 4 V as you cross the resistor to Va.

Does that help?
so that means the voltage drop across the resistor is 2v, then using V=IR
i get 2mA?

or do i use Nodal Analysis?
 
KTiaam said:
so that means the voltage drop across the resistor is 2v, then using V=IR
i get 2mA?
Yes. :smile:

Since Vb is at a higher potential than Va, what does that tell you about the direction of the current?

KTiaam said:
or do i use Nodal Analysis?
Nodal analysis is useful when you need to solve for unknown node voltages, but you're already given the node voltages on either side of the resistor, so all there's left to do is just apply Ohm's law.
 
milesyoung said:
Yes. :smile:

Since Vb is at a higher potential than Va, what does that tell you about the direction of the current?

Current goes from a high to low potential so it goes from right to left!

Thank you for all the help Miles! I might have more questions incoming lol.
 

Similar threads

Replies
18
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top