News Colin Powell Resigns: Distancing from Iraq & 2008?

  • Thread starter Thread starter adrenaline
  • Start date Start date
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the potential candidacy of Colin Powell for the presidency in 2008 and his distancing from the Iraq War. There is skepticism about Powell's motivation to run, given his past statements against seeking public office and the challenges he faced, particularly regarding the evidence presented for the Iraq invasion. Speculation arises about his departure from the UN and strained relations with key figures like Donald Rumsfeld. Personal factors, such as a promise to his wife concerning the dangers of being the first Black president, are also mentioned as influencing his decision not to run in previous elections. The conversation touches on historical context, questioning whether any bad presidents have been assassinated, with references to figures like Warren Harding and James Garfield, suggesting that perceptions of presidential effectiveness can be subjective and influenced by circumstances beyond their control.
adrenaline
Science Advisor
Messages
103
Reaction score
3
Is he distancing himself from Iraq and or possible run as a candidate in 2008?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I still just don't see him being very motivated to run for President (but, who knows what four years can bring?)

I think the main reason is that he's the peg that doesn't fit. He always winds up presenting the opposing view point. Frustrating in any event - probably especially so when the evidence given you to support the opposing view turns out to be false.
 
Considering all he's been through its a surprise it took this long, well in reality it could not have happened earlier but he's been a "ghost" for a while ... the UN disaster where he presented the "evidence" for one was a huge bummer, wonder was giving up his post his own idea (we'll probably never now but ...) ?
 
BobG said:
I still just don't see him being very motivated to run for President (but, who knows what four years can bring?)
In the past he's been pretty explicit about not ever wanting to run for public office. Disappointing.
 
russ_watters said:
In the past he's been pretty explicit about not ever wanting to run for public office. Disappointing.
Do you know why he decided not to run for President in '96? Was it out of Respect for Clinton, was it him thinking he couldn't beat Clinton (regardless of how he felt), or something else?
 
adrenaline said:
Is he distancing himself from Iraq and or possible run as a candidate in 2008?

I suspect that he was asked to leave. His relations with Rummy have been strained for a long time. Powell also spoke out against the evidence used to justify the invasion.
 
wasteofo2 said:
Do you know why he decided not to run for President in '96? Was it out of Respect for Clinton, was it him thinking he couldn't beat Clinton (regardless of how he felt), or something else?


Among other things, a promise to his wife. The first black president will have to accept that assasination is a high possibility, and Colin's wife voiced that worry to him.
 
phatmonky said:
Among other things, a promise to his wife. The first black president will have to accept that assasination is a high possibility, and Colin's wife voiced that worry to him.
Sad, but true... And he'd be such a great President too.

Has there ever been a BAD president that was assasinated? No one ever tried to kill Hoover or anything...
 
wasteofo2 said:
Sad, but true... And he'd be such a great President too.

Has there ever been a BAD president that was assasinated? No one ever tried to kill Hoover or anything...

Some people think that Warren Harding was murdered. That's not quite the same as assassinated, but he certainly was a bad president. For that matter Garfield was no great shakes.
 
  • #10
selfAdjoint said:
For that matter Garfield was no great shakes.

What great shakes can one expect from a 6 month term ?
 
  • #11
Gokul43201 said:
What great shakes can one expect from a 6 month term ?
My prespective exactly.

Garfield had SUCH potential. I just can't stand how everyone so flippantly writes him off as a failure. How much did THEIR favorite president get done in his first half a year in office?! :cry:
 

Similar threads

Replies
23
Views
7K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
25
Views
4K
Replies
19
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top