Combinations for word parallelogram

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the number of ways to select four letters from the word "parallelogram," with the book stating the answer is 150. Participants debate whether to use combinations based on unique letters or to account for repeated letters. It is clarified that the question allows for selecting any four letters, including duplicates, which affects the total combinations. The confusion arises from the interpretation of the question, particularly regarding whether selections like "aaap" and "aapl" should be counted as distinct. Ultimately, the ambiguity in the question leads to differing calculations and interpretations of the total combinations.
haribol
Messages
52
Reaction score
0
How many ways can you select four letters out of the word parallelogram ?

The answer on the book is 150. For me I am stuck at using 8C4 and it seems to be the logical way. The reason I chose 8 is because some letters are repeating. So how can they have 150?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
4 letters or 4 different letters?

cookiemonster
 
It just says four letters, not four different letters
 
You can't just remove those letters since you can have a combo of aaap and aapl and aplo. Eliminating those letters will eliminate a lot of your combinations.
 
I see, but 13C4 is quite big relative to 150 and I see no way how its 150
 
Well, one thing is that para and para, while different selections, constitute the same 4 letters, I suppose, so shouldn't both be counted. The question as stated is vague on this point!
 
The original question from the text is as follows:

"Determine the number of ways of selecting, without regard to order, from the word parallelogram"
 
Back
Top