Conceptual - Dot Product and Work

  • Thread starter Thread starter mybrohshi5
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Conceptual Work
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of work done by a force, expressed through the integral of the dot product of force and displacement. The participants analyze three statements regarding the dot product's implications on work, concluding that the first statement is false because work can be negative, while the third statement is true, indicating that only the parallel component of force contributes to work. The second statement is deemed false as it incorrectly suggests that perpendicular force components contribute to work. Clarifications are provided on how the direction of force relative to motion affects the sign of work done. Overall, the conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding the dot product in the context of work and force direction.
mybrohshi5
Messages
365
Reaction score
0
Conceptual ---- Work

Homework Statement



In general, the work done by a force F_vec is written as

W=\int_{\rm i}^{\rm f} \vec{F}(\vec{r})\cdot d\vec{r}.

Now, consider whether the following statements are true or false:


1) The dot product assures that the integrand is always nonnegative.
2) The dot product indicates that only the component of the force perpendicular to the
path contributes to the integral.
3) The dot product indicates that only the component of the force parallel to the path
contributes to the integral.

Homework Equations



n/a

The Attempt at a Solution



To be honest i have no idea about these. My professor doesn't teach, my book (which i just looked through for about 15 mins) doesn't talk about this anywhere, and yet it is on my homework :(

This is what i was thinking but i am really again not sure.

1) true
2) false
3) true

Thanks for any help.
 
Physics news on Phys.org


Write (Provide) vector definition of the dot product.
 


By guessing or otherwise, you got two of them right, and one of them wrong. If a particle moves to the right and the force acting on it is to the right, is the work done by the force positive or negative? If the particle moves to the right and the force acting on it is to the left, is the work done by the force positive or negative?
 


This is what i found in my book.

Scalar product -> A . B = ABcos(theta)
 


PhanthomJay said:
By guessing or otherwise, you got two of them right, and one of them wrong. If a particle moves to the right and the force acting on it is to the right, is the work done by the force positive or negative? If the particle moves to the right and the force acting on it is to the left, is the work done by the force positive or negative?

moves to the right and force acting on it is to the right then work is POSITIVE.

moves to the right and force acting on it is to the left then work is NEGATIVE

so... is this saying that 1) is actually false because it can be negative?
 


mybrohshi5 said:
moves to the right and force acting on it is to the right then work is POSITIVE.
yes...
moves to the right and force acting on it is to the left then work is NEGATIVE
yes...
so... is this saying that 1) is actually false because it can be negative?
I am hesitating to give answers to true-false questions, so it is up to you to decide...:smile:
 


Thank you :)
 
Back
Top