Confusion regarding Standing Waves and Reflection resulting in Phase Change

2 replies · 5K views · last reply
Hereformore
Messages
61
Reaction score
0
So a standing wave is one which looks to be standing still at certain harmonic frequencies. At these frequencies, when the wave reflects off the end, it will undergo a phase change of 180 degrees. This creates constructive interference as shown below:

Diagram of a transverse wave reflecting off a barrier on the right: incident, reflected and red resultant waves shown, with labels explaining the 180 degree phase change on reflection.


In the case of a wave on a string, since that would constitute a transverse wave, when the wave hits a barrier, much like with thin film interference, the reflected wave is shifted by 180 degrees.

in the case of a longitudinal wave, such as with an open-closed or open open air pressure system, the phase change occurs at the open end(s) but not at the closed ends.

What I don't understand is, if the reflected wave is constructive, and in phase with the incident wave, then why are standing wave diagrams always drawn with the reflected wave out of phase/having destructive interference? Am i misinterpreting the diagrams?

See below for standing waves:
Diagram of a standing wave on a string of length L fixed at both ends, showing two loops with nodes N at the ends and between loops and antinodes A at loop centres.

See below for Longitudinal waves:
Diagram of a standing wave in a tube of length L = λ/2 with open ends, showing the incident and reflected waves drawn as solid and dashed curves between two open-end labels.
(Open Open = phase change at both ends)
Diagram of the first normal mode of an open-closed air column, with a closed end at left and an open end at right, labelled L = lambda/4 and f1 = v/4L; a pressure curve rises from the closed end and a dashed displacement curve falls toward the open end.
Open Closed = Phase change only at open end.

Also otherwise, is my understanding of what's going on (with the reflections and phase changes) accurate? Thanks guys!
 
Hereformore said:
So a standing wave is one which looks to be standing still at certain harmonic frequencies. At these frequencies, when the wave reflects off the end, it will undergo a phase change of 180 degrees. This creates constructive interference as shown below:

View attachment 74816

180 degrees phase change results in destructive interference, that is, why there is a node at the barrier.
 
ehild said:
180 degrees phase change results in destructive interference, that is, why there is a node at the barrier.
but then how does the standing wave occur if the reflection always causes destructive interference?

OH Is it that at each point in between nodes the incident and reflected/incoming wave interact differently to different degrees of constructive and destructive, such that at the antinode its total constructive and at the node its total descrtuctive and in between its a gradient?