Constant vector and cross product?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around evaluating the expression grad x (k x r) where k is a constant vector. Participants clarify that the specific values of k are not necessary to solve the problem, as assuming an arbitrary vector form (ai + bj + ck) suffices. There is a discrepancy in the answers, with one participant arriving at -2ai - 2bj - 2ck, while another calculates 2ai + 2bj + 2ck, indicating a sign difference. The conversation emphasizes understanding the process rather than the exact values of k. Ultimately, clarity is achieved regarding the interpretation of the results.
jlmac2001
Messages
75
Reaction score
0
Okay, here's the question:

For r=xi + yj +zk evaluate grad x (k x r), where k is a constant vector.

I know how to do the cross product of k x r and I know how to do
grad x (k x r). But I don't know what k is. What's k?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Originally posted by jlmac2001
... But I don't know what k is. What's k?
Try assuming an arbitrary k vector: ai + bj + ck (or whatever). Then see what happens.
 
does this look right?

The answer I got is: -2ai-2bj-2ck
 


Originally posted by jlmac2001
The answer I got is: -2ai-2bj-2ck
I got 2k (where k is the constant vector) but I did it quick. (So my answer differs by a minus sign from yours.) My main point was that you didn't have to know the value of k (the a, b, & c) to do the problem.
 
question

how did you just get 2k? i don't understand
 


Originally posted by jlmac2001
how did you just get 2k? i don't understand
By "2k" I mean: 2ai + 2bj + 2ck. (The same as you, but with a + instead of -.) 2\vec{k} is what I should have written. Make sense?
 
thanks

i get it now
 
Back
Top