Cool Gas with Ionisation - Can High Voltage Do It?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PH7SICS
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Cool Gas
AI Thread Summary
Using high voltage to ionize gas by removing electrons may not result in a cooling effect, as typically, the creation of plasma from gas leads to increased temperatures. The discussion revolves around whether ionizing gas lowers its energy state and consequently its temperature, with some participants questioning the logic behind this assumption. The principle of E=mc² is referenced to argue that removing electrons reduces mass and energy, but this is challenged by the notion that ionization could impart kinetic energy to the remaining particles, raising the temperature instead. Overall, the feasibility of using this ionization process for cooling applications remains uncertain and requires further expert analysis.
PH7SICS
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
If you use high voltage to rip electrons away from gas molecules thus forming ions will this have a cooling effect on the gas? Removing electrons from an atom must bring it to a lower energy state, will that lower energy state manifest itself as a lowering in temperature?

Could you use this principle to cool an object?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
they have laser cooling i don't know if that quite what you are asking.
 
I was thinking of its application to cool a jet of gas. Here is a quick sketch. Pressurised gas flows through a nozzle which has sharp points attached to a EHT. The electrons are ripped from the gas thus ionising it as it passes over the grid. Will the temperature of the gas be reduced?
 

Attachments

  • jetcooler.JPG
    jetcooler.JPG
    7.4 KB · Views: 538
usually when a plasma is created it gets hotter.
 
cragar said:
usually when a plasma is created it gets hotter.


A plasma would be created if you used a massive amount of electrical energy, considering the fact that we are dealing with gas at pressure. I however was just thinking about the production of ionised gas as opposed to a plasma state.
 
perhaps you theory is to deep for me to comprehend and we need more expert opinions
 
PH7SICS said:
If you use high voltage to rip electrons away from gas molecules thus forming ions will this have a cooling effect on the gas? Removing electrons from an atom must bring it to a lower energy state, will that lower energy state manifest itself as a lowering in temperature?

Could you use this principle to cool an object?

Why do you think ionizing an atom will lower its internal energy?
 
Andy Resnick said:
Why do you think ionizing an atom will lower its internal energy?

E= MC2 matter is energy and you are removing matter (electrons) from the atom you must be reducing its energy level as you are reducing its mass?
 
PH7SICS said:
E= MC2 matter is energy and you are removing matter (electrons) from the atom you must be reducing its energy level as you are reducing its mass?

Are you implying that lighter objects are colder than heavier objects? Or that cutting an apple in half somehow cools the apple?
 
  • #10
Andy Resnick said:
Are you implying that lighter objects are colder than heavier objects? Or that cutting an apple in half somehow cools the apple?


No, I was answering your question, you asked why I thought ionizing an atom would reduce its energy. If you are removing matter from an atom are you not reducing its energy according to E=MC2 ??

As for my thoughts to why this may cool a gas I have noticed that atoms/molecules tend to eject matter to lower their energy level. That matter could be in the from of photons or electrons but after this mater has been ejected the atom jumps down to a lower energy state. If that is so why wouldn't ripping electrons from an atom cause its energy state to be reduced (this applys to positive ions only)

I am not saying positive ions are stable. If they are at a lover energy level then the environment they will obviously attract electrons to get to the same energy level as the environment and thus archive equilibrium.
 
  • #11
How are you planning to "rip" an electron away from a nucleus without giving the nucleus a BOOST in kinetic energy (and thus temperature)?
 

Similar threads

Replies
14
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
42
Views
11K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
14K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Back
Top