Creep Testing Help - Secondary creep rate

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around understanding secondary creep rate (E) in materials testing, specifically for lead. The participant graphed extension against time to derive E but is confused about using the equation E = A stress^n e^(-Qc/RT) without knowing constants A and Qc. The conversation clarifies that E can be estimated from the slope of a log-log plot of stress versus creep rate, allowing for the determination of the stress exponent n. The participant is encouraged to focus on the relationship between stress and creep rate, as the constants A and Qc will not affect the slope used to find n. Ultimately, the key takeaway is that understanding the log-log relationship simplifies the analysis of secondary creep without needing all parameters.
DdotT
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
I tested creep in the labs at univeristy, one thing i am confused about is, we made a graph of the extension against time. Taking the gradient gives us E or secondary creep rate.

Homework Statement




The equation for this (without using gradient ) is, E= A stress^n e^-Qc/RT

A and n are constants ( i know n is the stress exponent which for the material (lead) was 10)

Qc is the activation energy, can't find anything about this.

R is universal gas constant 8.31 J/mol K

Note: the test was done at room temperature.

T is absolute temp.



Really confused by this, the experiment helper didn't explain any of this.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
DdotT said:
I tested creep in the labs at univeristy, one thing i am confused about is, we made a graph of the extension against time. Taking the gradient gives us E or secondary creep rate.

Homework Statement




The equation for this (without using gradient ) is, E= A stress^n e^-Qc/RT

A and n are constants ( i know n is the stress exponent which for the material (lead) was 10)

Qc is the activation energy, can't find anything about this.

R is universal gas constant 8.31 J/mol K

Note: the test was done at room temperature.

T is absolute temp.



Really confused by this, the experiment helper didn't explain any of this.

Hi DdotT, welcome to PF! What are you trying to do? Is the problem to estimate one of the parameters?
 
Mapes said:
Hi DdotT, welcome to PF! What are you trying to do? Is the problem to estimate one of the parameters?

No the 'thing' i need to do is draw up curves for the 3 specimens (extension against time), work out the stress , work out the secondary creep rate, then take natural logs of these, then plot a final graph with the natural logs, take the gradient of the line of best fit, that gives me the stress exponent (10 in lead's case).
However, this is what the experiment helper told us to do, in our booklets are the formula i stated, i do not understand how i would use this formula / get the secondary creep rate ε without taking the gradient.
 
OK, got it. You should first plot extension vs. time. Secondary creep occurs after an initial transient and before rapid failure; it is a region of relatively constant creep rate. Find this creep rate. This will be E in your equation above. Note that it depends exponentially on stress. So plot the stress vs. creep rate on a log-log scale; the slope of the line is an estimate of the exponent. Does this make sense?
 
Mapes said:
OK, got it. You should first plot extension vs. time. Secondary creep occurs after an initial transient and before rapid failure; it is a region of relatively constant creep rate. Find this creep rate. This will be E in your equation above. Note that it depends exponentially on stress. So plot the stress vs. creep rate on a log-log scale; the slope of the line is an estimate of the exponent. Does this make sense?

yh i understand this, and its relation to the exponent.
its the equation of: ε = A σ^n e^ Qc / RT

E is the secondary creep rate , stress is σ, n is the stress exponent of lead which is 10, Qc os the 'activation energy' for creep in the metal, R universal gas constant and T is temp.

How do i use this equation ?

i have stress, n , R, T (room temp i think).
I do not know Qc or A. It says A and n are constants.
So i really don't understand how to use this.

Sorry if i didnt make it clear what i needed help with.
 
DdotT said:
yh i understand this, and its relation to the exponent.
its the equation of: ε = A σ^n e^ Qc / RT

E is the secondary creep rate , stress is σ, n is the stress exponent of lead which is 10, Qc os the 'activation energy' for creep in the metal, R universal gas constant and T is temp.

How do i use this equation ?

i have stress, n , R, T (room temp i think).
I do not know Qc or A. It says A and n are constants.
So i really don't understand how to use this.

Sorry if i didnt make it clear what i needed help with.

You know that ε = E here, right? Just checking.
 
Mapes said:
You know that ε = E here, right? Just checking.

yes, i just don't know what to subsitute for things like A and Qc
 
DdotT said:
yes, i just don't know what to subsitute for things like A and Qc

Does it matter? What happens when you take the log of ε = A σ^n e^ Qc / RT?
 
Mapes said:
Does it matter? What happens when you take the log of ε = A σ^n e^ Qc / RT?

lnε = ln A + nlnσ - Qc / RT

but we still need to know Qc and constant A? i just don't understand it x( sorry
 
  • #10
DdotT said:
lnε = ln A + nlnσ - Qc / RT

but we still need to know Qc and constant A? i just don't understand it x( sorry

When one considers dlnε/dlnσ = n (i.e., the slope of ε vs. σ on a log-log chart), all other parameters go away. Know what I mean?
 
  • #11
Mapes said:
When one considers dlnε/dlnσ = n (i.e., the slope of ε vs. σ on a log-log chart), all other parameters go away. Know what I mean?

yes, it makes more sense know. thank you.
 
  • #12
Hi
I am new to it. Still don't understand. Can you help with this:
I have known: 1 stess and 1 creep rate; 2 stress and 2 creep rate; 3 stress and need to calculate 3 creep rate based on the above.
The temperature is constant. the same all the time.
s1; e1
s2; e2
s3; ?
What is the easiest way to do it?
 
Back
Top