Deriving expression for resistance in terms of current density

7 replies · 3K views · last reply
spindecide
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Is there a way to obtain equation 9.42 (I is current, j is current density, and sigma is conductivity) in the following image (from Modern Electrodynamics by Andrew Zangwill, the part on electromotive force) besides using V=IR and substituting the line integral of j/conductivity for V? The aforementioned way requires that j=conductivity*E, but due to the emf, j should be equal to conductivity*[E + E'], where E' is a fictitious electric field representing the effect of any source of EMF.
Textbook page section 9.7.1 Voltage Difference showing equations 9.40 to 9.44: voltage difference integral, EMF integral with E prime, resistance R12 as an integral of j over sigma, and IR12 equals V1 minus V2 plus EMF.
 
I think this equation is reasonable and I don't see any problem with it.

Handwritten derivation: R12 = (1/(I σ)) ∫ from 1 to 2 of dl · j = (1/I) ∫ from 1 to 2 of dl · (E + E') = L12 (E + E') / (j A). Below: Thus R12 = L12 / (A σ), because (E + E') / j = 1/σ.
 
spindecide said:
But how is R written as the first integral?
My personal opinion as follow.

Handwritten equations in blue ink: R12 = (1/I) integral from 1 to 2 of E dot dl = (1/(I sigma)) integral from 1 to 2 of J dot dl.
 
But j is not just equal to sigma times E as the effect of the emf needs to be considered, so that j equals sigma times (E + E').
 
A very useful equation is shown here
Textbook page section 9.7.1 Voltage Difference showing equations 9.40 to 9.44, with equation 9.43 (IR12 = V1 - V2 + EMF12 = phi1 - phi2 + EMF12) highlighted in a yellow box.
$$ V_1-V_2=IR_{12}-\varepsilon _{12}~~~~~\Rightarrow ~~~~~V_1-V_2=IR_{12}-\int_1^2~dl\cdot~E^{'} $$ That is to say, the voltage difference in a circuit with EMF is not equal to IR, but equal to IR minus EMF. This is actually an equation very familiar and commonly used by electrical and electronics engineers when conducting circuit analysis.

It is also worth noting that $$IR_{12}=(V_1-V_2)+\varepsilon _{12}=\int_1^2~dl\cdot~(E+E^{'}),~~~~\text{so}~~R=\frac {1}{I} \int_1^2~dl\cdot~(E+E^{'}) $$
Everything is in perfect harmony, without contradictions. :smile:
 
Last edited:
spindecide said:
But j is not just equal to sigma times E as the effect of the emf needs to be considered, so that j equals sigma times (E + E').
You are right, I accidentally wrote the equation wrong.
 
alan123hk said:
You are right, I accidentally wrote the equation wrong.
Can we please stop this split electric field nonsense???
Please.
 
  • Love
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: weirdoguy and vanhees71