Difference between Yield stress and Proportional Limit

4 replies · 34K views · last reply
Saladsamurai
Messages
3,009
Reaction score
7
Is there a difference, when looking at the stress-strain diagram, between the "Proportional Limit stress" and the "Yield Stress" ?

Thanks!
 
I picked up my old "Introduction to mechanics of solids" text by Egor P. Popov and it states the following:
A study of stress-strain diagrams shows that the yield point is so near the proportional limit that for most purposes the two may be taken as one. However, it is much easier to locate the former. For materials which do not possesses a well-defined yield point, one is actually "invented" by the use of the so-call offset method.
Hope this helps a little.
 
So, looking at this stress-strain curve, would you say that the proportional limit and the upper yield are in distinguishable?

Stress-strain curve titled Hot-Rolled Steel, plotting sigma in MPa against strain epsilon in mm/mm. Linear rise to about 380 MPa at 0.03 strain, then a wavy plateau near 370 to 390 MPa, rising to a peak sigma_u near 430 MPa at 0.18, then falling to about 250 MPa at 0.23.
 
I would say yes but the porportional limit is somewhat vaguely defined.
 
That's because I defined it. I have no way of telling exactly where the non-linear curve begins... so I just "eyeballed'" it.