Direction of current when performing KCL

AI Thread Summary
Determining the direction of current flow in nodal analysis can initially be uncertain, as one must assume a direction. If the assumption is incorrect, the result will be negative, but this does not affect the overall correctness if Ohm's law is applied consistently. The key is to maintain consistency in assumptions, such as assuming all currents leave the node, which leads to accurate results despite potential misdirection. Using Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL) can be simplified by writing equations that sum to zero, which helps minimize mistakes. Proper application of these principles ensures reliable outcomes in circuit analysis.
Martin V.
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
Who do I know the direction of the current flow, when I make nodal analysis?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
A priori you do not. You can assume a direction and if the current actually flows in the other direction you will get a negative result.
 
#2: The problem occurs when I user Ohm's law, it can end up in the wrong results if the direction I assumed is wrong. Any solution to that?
 
Martin V. said:
#2: The problem occurs when I user Ohm's law, it can end up in the wrong results if the direction I assumed is wrong. Any solution to that?

No, this problem cannot occur if you use Ohm's law correctly. Ohm's law does not only state the absolute potential difference between two sides of the resistor, it states which sign the potential difference has. The potential is higher on the side the current comes from.
 
Martin V. said:
#2: The problem occurs when I user Ohm's law, it can end up in the wrong results if the direction I assumed is wrong. Any solution to that?

Perhaps post an example problem with your attempt to solve it so we can see where you are going wrong.
 
Martin V. said:
The problem occurs when I user Ohm's law, it can end up in the wrong results if the direction I assumed is wrong.
If you do everything consistently then you will never get wrong results, even when you assume a wrong direction. Because of this, I always assume that every current is leaving the node. I know that at least one of those assumptions is wrong, but by being consistent I still come out with the right answer.
 
There are two ways two write KCL...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirchhoff's_circuit_laws

At any node (junction) in an electrical circuit, the sum of currents flowing into that node is equal to the sum of currents flowing out of that node
or equivalently
The algebraic sum of currents in a network of conductors meeting at a point is zero.

Personally I find I make fewer mistakes if I use the latter of the two definitions and write an equation that sums to zero. eg..

A + B + C... = 0
rather than say
D + E = -F -G
 
Back
Top