Do electrons flow in an electrical circuit?

In summary: BTW, all analogies are wrong at some level, that's why they are called analogies instead of theories.
  • #1
sevensages
59
9


The video on youtube on the above link seems to imply that electrons don't flow through a circuit. At 01:29 into the video, the narrator says that he used to teach his classes how electrons move through a circuit by using a clear plastic tube with a chain inside of the clear plastic tube. The narrator would say that power lines are like the clear plastic tubing. He had a chain inside of the clear plastic tubing. He said that the chain was like the electrons in the wire of the power line. He moved the chain back and forth, without moving any link in the chain throughout the entire circuit. Before I watched this youtube video, this was how I understand electrons to travel through a circuit. However, the narrator said that this is wrong. In other words, the narrator used to teach his classes how electrons move through a circuit in a way that was incorrect.

My understanding of the video is that the narrator is saying that electrons don't move in an electromagnetic circuit.

My father says that an electromagnetic field cannot be generated without having electrons moving around in the wire. If the electrons don't move in a circuit, how can an electromagnetic field be generated?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Please be careful not to put too much trust into simplified analogies of how electricity and electronics work.

The key term for you to do a Google search on is the drift velocity of electrons in circuits. In an AC circuit, the electrons indeed do not stray very far from their quiescent locales, since their motion is back and forth (over pretty short distances). In DC circuits of course electrons move through the circuit, albeit a lot more slowly than you would expect until you calculate their drift velocity.
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71, dlgoff and phinds
  • #3
berkeman said:
Please be careful not to put too much trust into simplified analogies of how electricity and electronics work.

The key term for you to do a Google search on is the drift velocity of electrons in circuits. In an AC circuit, the electrons indeed do not stray very far from their quiescent locales, since their motion is back and forth (over pretty short distances). In DC circuits of course electrons move through the circuit, albeit a lot more slowly than you would expect until you calculate their drift velocity.
Searching on Microscopic View of Electric Current gives this fine explanation from hyperphysics:
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/electric/miccur.html
 
  • Love
  • Like
Likes vanhees71 and berkeman
  • #4
sevensages said:
My understanding of the video is that the narrator is saying that electrons don't move in an electromagnetic circuit.
That is not what to take home from the video.
It is about power transfer - from a pure physics explanation the field is the explanation, not the electrons themselves.
In most electrical circuits, it is modeled as if the current is doing the 'work,' and the field is paid scant attention.

Ask yourself, if the electrons do not move, how do capacitors become polarized.
How does the phospher on a crt screen become exited so that you see a picture.
 
  • Like
Likes nsaspook and vanhees71
  • #5
256bits said:
It is about power transfer - from a pure physics explanation the field is the explanation, not the electrons themselves.
Yes. From my hyperphysics link above:
...the actual drift velocity of electrons through copper wires is very slow. It is the change or "signal" which propagates along wires at essentially the speed of light. ...
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71 and 256bits
  • #6
sevensages said:
My understanding of the video is that the narrator is saying that electrons don't move in an electromagnetic circuit.
He didn't say they don't move. He said they don't have to move very far. I thought that was pretty clear with his chain analogy. Watch it again. Another analogy is waves in the ocean. A wave can travel from Hawaii to California, but each water molecule doesn't move very far at all. BTW, all analogies are wrong at some level, that's why they are called analogies instead of theories.

However, that is for circuits, with wires and such. You'll also want to think about how radio waves transfer energy across the vacuum of space, where there are essentially no charged particles. Yes, moving charges created those waves, but they don't have to stay with the waves forever (or at all). You can have e-fields and h-fields without charges. But charged particles, if present, will react to EM fields they experience.
 
  • Like
Likes 256bits, vanhees71 and sysprog
  • #7
NB: The drift velocity in a copper wire for typical houshold currents is on the order of 1mm/s only. The energy flow, given by the Poynting vector is due to the em. field.

As usual, the best treatment about the (apparently!) simple case of a DC through a coax cable is given in Sommerfeld, Lectures on Theoretical Physics, vol. 3 (electrodynamics).
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes 256bits and dlgoff
  • #8
DaveE said:
He didn't say they don't move. He said they don't have to move very far. I thought that was pretty clear with his chain analogy. Watch it again. Another analogy is waves in the ocean. A wave can travel from Hawaii to California, but each water molecule doesn't move very far at all. BTW, all analogies are wrong at some level, that's why they are called analogies instead of theories.
The links of his chain did not move very far in his chain analogy. He just shifted the chain back and forth about two or three inches. Each link of the chain did not move throughout the entire circuit. So he didn't move the chain very far, yet he still said that the chain analogy is wrong. If the electrons only move very slightly, how is his chain analogy wrong?
 
  • #9
berkeman said:
In an AC circuit, the electrons indeed do not stray very far from their quiescent locales, since their motion is back and forth (over pretty short distances).
In his chain analogy, he didn't move the chain very far. He only moved the chain about two or three inches in each direction. Then he said that the chain analogy is wrong. Well, if he only moved the chain about two or three inches in his chain analogy, then how is his chain analogy wrong?

berkeman said:
In DC circuits of course electrons move through the circuit, albeit a lot more slowly than you would expect until you calculate their drift velocity.
 
  • Like
Likes 256bits
  • #10
sevensages said:
Well, if he only moved the chain about two or three inches in his chain analogy, then how is his chain analogy wrong?
It's wrong only in amplitude, unless he was demonstrating huge AC currents. When you Google displacement current like I suggested and look at the numbers, you will see that the movement of the electrons in a 60Hz AC mains circuit is much less than a few inches per cycle.
 
  • Like
Likes sevensages and 256bits
  • #11
sevensages said:
how is his chain analogy wrong?
The point of the video is how energy is propagating. This is where the chain analogy breaks down.
 
  • Like
Likes nsaspook
  • #12
berkeman said:
It's wrong only in amplitude, unless he was demonstrating huge AC currents. When you Google displacement current like I suggested and look at the numbers, you will see that the movement of the electrons in a 60Hz AC mains circuit is much less than a few inches per cycle.

I googled displacement current like you suggested, and I could not tell the answer from what I saw on google.

If the narrator of the video moved the chain only about a milimeter (or maybe only a nanometer), would the chain analogy be a lot more accurate?
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
  • #13
sevensages said:
I googled displacement current like you suggested, and I could not tell the answer from what I saw on google.
https://www.uu.edu/dept/physics/scienceguys/2001Nov.cfm

sevensages said:
If the narrator of the video moved the chain only about a milimeter (or maybe only a nanometer), would the chain analogy be a lot more accurate?
Yes, much more accurate (see above). :smile:
 
  • Like
Likes sevensages
  • #14
berkeman said:
It's wrong only in amplitude, unless he was demonstrating huge AC currents. When you Google displacement current like I suggested and look at the numbers, you will see that the movement of the electrons in a 60Hz AC mains circuit is much less than a few inches per cycle.
What has "displacement current" to do with the drift velocity of electrons in a wire? Nothing! Displacement current is an old-fashioned name for a term in the Ampere-Maxwell Law, which has been written as (in Heaviside-Lorentz units)
$$\mathrm{\nabla} \times \vec{B}=\frac{1}{c} \vec{j} +\frac{1}{c} \partial_t \vec{E}.$$
The last term is, even today, still called "displacement current". It originates from Maxwell's original ideas using mechanical models to "derive" his famous equations. Today, more than 160 years later, we know a lot more about the structure of Maxwell's equations. Most notably the discovery that it is a relativistic field theory, has taught us to write the equation as
$$\mathrm{\nabla} \times \vec{B} - \frac{1}{c} \partial_t \vec{E}=\frac{1}{c} \vec{j},$$
with the current density (i.e., moving electric charges) as the only source of the electromagnetic field, ##(\vec{E},\vec{B})##.

For household AC the displacement current can very often be neglected, at least as long as we deal with phenomena in the "near area" around the circuit, i.e., in a region of extension smaller than the wave-length, ##\lambda=c/f \simeq 5\cdot 10^6 \text{m}## :-)).
 
  • Like
Likes tech99
  • #15
vanhees71 said:
What has "displacement current" to do with the drift velocity of electrons in a wire?
You are right, of course. I someplace used the incorrect term and it kept propagating. It should have been drift current, not displacement current. Thanks for the correction! :smile:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drift_current
 
  • Like
Likes vanhees71

1. Do electrons flow in an electrical circuit?

Yes, electrons do flow in an electrical circuit. They are the carriers of electric charge and are responsible for the flow of electricity through a circuit.

2. How do electrons flow in an electrical circuit?

Electrons flow in an electrical circuit due to the presence of an electric field. This field is created by a voltage difference between two points in the circuit, causing electrons to move from the negative terminal to the positive terminal of a battery or power source.

3. What is the direction of electron flow in an electrical circuit?

The direction of electron flow in an electrical circuit is from the negative terminal to the positive terminal. This is opposite to the conventional current flow, which is from the positive terminal to the negative terminal.

4. Why do electrons flow in an electrical circuit?

Electrons flow in an electrical circuit because of the principle of charge conservation. This means that the total amount of charge in a closed system remains constant, so when electrons flow out of one point in a circuit, an equal amount of electrons must flow into another point to maintain this balance.

5. Can electrons flow in a circuit with no power source?

No, electrons cannot flow in a circuit without a power source. The power source, such as a battery or generator, provides the necessary voltage difference to create an electric field and allow the flow of electrons. Without this, there is no force to move the electrons and no flow of electricity.

Similar threads

Replies
14
Views
933
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
1K
Replies
21
Views
2K
  • Electromagnetism
2
Replies
36
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
771
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
7
Views
6K
Replies
1
Views
753
Replies
1
Views
971
  • Electromagnetism
Replies
2
Views
1K
Back
Top