Does Special Relativity Affect the Perception of Simultaneous Events in Motion?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the effects of special relativity on the perception of simultaneous events, specifically two rocket explosions observed from different frames of reference. The observer on the ground sees both explosions occur simultaneously, while a spaceship traveling at 0.7c must account for relativistic effects. Calculations show that the distance between the two students, as perceived by the spaceship crew, is 71.4m, leading to a time calculation of approximately 3.4 x 10^-7 seconds for the spaceship to traverse this distance. However, the crew must also determine the time interval between the explosions as observed from their frame, which involves understanding how simultaneity differs between observers. The discussion emphasizes the importance of calculating the time of events based on the observer's frame to understand the non-simultaneity of events in motion.
Jalo
Messages
117
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Two students on the ground, separated 100m from each other, launch one rocket each vertically. The rocket explode at the same time for an observer, on the ground, that's midway between the rocket explosion. At the exact time the observer sees the rockets exploding a spaceship flies over his head, horizontally, at a speed of 0.7c. The ship length as seen by the observer is 15m.

(c)How much time goes by, to a tripulant of the spaceship, for the ship to complete the 100m between the two students?
(d)For a tripulant of the spaceship is the explosion of the rockets simultaneous? What's the time interval? (time between the first rocket explosion and the second, as seen by the tripulant)


Homework Equations



After solving the first two questions I've reached this data:
Actual distance between the two students = 71.4m
Spaceship length as measured by the tripulant = 21m

As to question (c) I used the equation t=d/v to solve it.

The Attempt at a Solution



(c) I think I've done her correctly. I've simply divided the length between the two students as seen by a tripulant in a ship by her speed:
t=71.4/0.7c=3.4*10^-7

(d) I know the explosions are not simultaneous, however I have no idea how I'm supposed to measure the time interval between the two explosions... If anyone could give me some hint, or some equation that could help me i'd be grateful. I've readen the whole relativity chapter of Serway's Physics for Scientists looking for something to help me without any luck.

Thanks, and a happy new year to everyone.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
For part d:
The time interval between any two events, such as the two explosions, is the difference between the times at which they happen... And those times may be different for different observers, which is why things that are simultaneous (happened at the same time, so difference is zero) for one observer may not be simultaneous for another observer.

So you need to figure out the time of the two explosions, as observed from the spaceship. Then you can calculate the interval between those two times.
 
Nugatory said:
For part d:
The time interval between any two events, such as the two explosions, is the difference between the times at which they happen... And those times may be different for different observers, which is why things that are simultaneous (happened at the same time, so difference is zero) for one observer may not be simultaneous for another observer.

So you need to figure out the time of the two explosions, as observed from the spaceship. Then you can calculate the interval between those two times.

I understand that, is the how that I'm having problems with :|
 
Since light will travel at the same speed from both sources the ratio of the times is the same as the ratio of the distances, so can you find the distance the ship is from each explosion when they go off?
 
JHamm said:
Since light will travel at the same speed from both sources the ratio of the times is the same as the ratio of the distances, so can you find the distance the ship is from each explosion when they go off?

When the explosion go off for the observer the ship is above his head, with the same x position
 
Jalo said:
Actual distance between the two students = 71.4m
Spaceship length as measured by the tripulant = 21m

As to question (c) I used the equation t=d/v to solve it.

The Attempt at a Solution



(c) I think I've done her correctly. I've simply divided the length between the two students as seen by a tripulant in a ship by her speed:
t=71.4/0.7c=3.4*10^-7

If by actual you mean distance b/w boys in spaceship frame ...

then why is d = 71.4 and not 71.4 + 21 :confused:
and 0.7c in in ground frame :confused::confused:

And won't this be a better way:
find time in ground frame and them convert it for spaceship ...
 
Nugatory said:
For part d:
The time interval between any two events, such as the two explosions, is the difference between the times at which they happen... And those times may be different for different observers, which is why things that are simultaneous (happened at the same time, so difference is zero) for one observer may not be simultaneous for another observer.

So you need to figure out the time of the two explosions, as observed from the spaceship. Then you can calculate the interval between those two times.

when you move, time slows down, but 0 time difference should remain 0

even in time dilation formula, put any 1 time 0 and other becomes 0 ...
 
Back
Top