Does the fabric of space itself cause friction?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around the concept of space having a texture that could create friction, potentially causing spacecraft to slow down even in a vacuum. This idea is not widely accepted, as it contradicts the principles of relativity, which state there is no preferred inertial frame of reference. The conversation references the Pioneer anomaly, which remains unexplained, and mentions Gravity Probe B, designed to test frame dragging—an effect where rotating bodies in spacetime cause it to drag along, likened to friction. However, while this frame dragging is analogous to friction in spacetime, it reportedly has no mechanical impact on objects, except in specific scenarios like the behavior of bodies near black holes. The debate highlights confusion over whether spacetime effects can be mechanically detected, with some asserting that they do have mechanical consequences.
whydoyouwanttoknow
Messages
39
Reaction score
0
I remember reading a while ago that the fabric of space has a texture and thus would cause friction. Even in a perfect vacuum a spacecraft would slow down over time due to this.

Is this an accepted theory?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
No; I am sure its not an accepted theory because it would violate the basic principles behind relativity(no preferred inertial frame of reference). I've never heard of that theory either.
 
I think that is one explanation put forth for the acceleration of Pioneer ten. No definitive answer was ever determined, AFAIK.
 
well, there is Gravity probe B that is out there testing for frame dragging. This is kind of like friction, since the rotation of a body in space time causes the space time to drag with the body. This is like a mass - space time friction but I am not sure if it has any effects on mechanical friction.
 
Nenad said:
well, there is Gravity probe B that is out there testing for frame dragging. This is kind of like friction, since the rotation of a body in space time causes the space time to drag with the body. This is like a mass - space time friction but I am not sure if it has any effects on mechanical friction.

Yes, this is like friction, but only to spacetime. But it has no effect on mechanics, except for how the spacetime is twisted therefore causing changes in how, for example a body is sucked into a black hole... it gets sucked in with a slight curve
 
Mk said:
for example a body is sucked into a black hole... it gets sucked in with a slight curve

No actually it doesnt. We cannot see or sense this curve in space time which creates gravity. The object would not be sucked in with a curve.
 
Mk said:
Yes, this is like friction, but only to spacetime. But it has no effect on mechanics, except for how the spacetime is twisted therefore causing changes in how, for example a body is sucked into a black hole... it gets sucked in with a slight curve

If it has no mechanical effect, then the mechanism of the probe will not detect it, will it?
 
Exackly, there we go. It does have mechanical effect.
 
Back
Top