Double Angle Identity Mystery: Solving 2/(tanx+cotx)=sinx

AI Thread Summary
The equation 2/(tanx+cotx)=sinx leads to the simplification 2sinxcosx, which equals sin(2x), not sinx. The original poster believes their solution is correct, while the textbook claims the answer is sinx. Participants in the discussion agree that the poster's solution appears accurate, suggesting a possible error in the textbook. The conversation indicates confusion over the problem's validity, but consensus leans towards the poster's interpretation being correct. The issue highlights potential discrepancies between textbook answers and student solutions.
nzashadow
Messages
10
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



2/(tanx+cotx)=sinx

Homework Equations



Double Angle Identities, Pythagorean Identities

The Attempt at a Solution



2/(tanx+cotx)=

2/[(sinx/cosx)+(cosx/sinx)]=

2/[((sinx)^2+(cosx)^2)/(sinxcosx)]=

2sinxcosx/[(sinx)^2+(cosx)^2]=

2sinxcosx = sin(2x) =/= sinx

The book I'm getting this problem in says the answer is sinx, however I get sin(2x) which does not equal sinx. I am certain I am right, though I may also be making a stupid mistake :P
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Your answer seems correct went over it a couple of times, It seems like an error with your textbook.
 
Seems correct to me too, maybe the textbook has tan(x/2)+cot(x/2) instead?
 
you are right
 
nah it says tanx+cotx, went over it many times.

thanks guys
 

Similar threads

Back
Top