Draw a free body diagram for the electric force

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on drawing free body diagrams and calculating the electric forces between three charges: Q1, Q2, and Q3. Participants emphasize the importance of using Coulomb's law to determine the forces, highlighting the need to accurately account for units, particularly microcoulombs. Confusion arises regarding the calculation of distances and the significance of negative signs in force calculations, with clarification provided that magnitudes are always positive. The direction of the forces is determined by the nature of the charges, with opposite charges attracting and like charges repelling. Understanding these concepts is crucial for solving the problem effectively.
Cglez1280
Messages
21
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


A positive charge Q1=7.4uC is located at a point X1=-2 m, a negative charge Q2=-9.7uC is located at a point X2=3m and a positive Q3=2.1uC is located at a point X3=9
A. Draw a free body diagram for the electric force acting on Q1, Q2, and Q3.
B. Find the magnitude of the force between Q1 and Q2
So like I have no idea what to do I'm completely lost this is ap physics summer work and I've never taken a physics class and this is just plain confusing

Not sure what would help.
Q1=-7.5 uC
Q2=-9.7 uC
Q3=2.1 uC
X1=-2 m
X2=3 m
X3=9 m

Homework Equations


I don't know

The Attempt at a Solution


I'm sorry but all I have is numbers that i don't know what to do with
 
Physics news on Phys.org
The total force acting on a body is the sum of all the forces acting on the body due to all other particles. If you know Coulomb's law this will help drawing the free body diagrams. Make sure you know the definition of a free body diagram. If you can add vectors, you can sum forces, since forces are represented by vectors.
 
Last edited:
Lucas SV said:
The total force acting on a body is the sum of all the forces acting on the body due to all other particles. If you know Coulumb's law this will help drawing the free body diagrams. Make sure you know the definition of a free body diagram. If you can add vectors, you can sum forces, since forces are represented by vectors.
Ok sorry to add that I already drew the free body diagrams but after that I'm confused.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    25 KB · Views: 1,004
Next step is applying Coulomb's law to find the forces between particles. You can start for example, by computing ##F_{12}##. You need to know the charges ##Q_1## and ##Q_2##, as well as the distance between these two charges.
 
Last edited:
Lucas SV said:
Next step is applying Coulumb's law to find the forces between particles. You can start for example, by computing ##F_{12}##. You need to know the charges ##Q_1## and ##Q_2##, as well as the distance between these two charges.
Ok so how would I do the distance. Since X1 is at -2m and X2 is at 3m would it be 5? Sorry for the dumb questions I'm just trying to make sure I can do the next few parts without help
 
Cglez1280 said:
Since X1 is at -2m and X2 is at 3m would it be 5?
Correct! Actually more precisely you should put 5m. Always make sure you put units in physical calculations.
 
Lucas SV said:
Correct! Actually more precisely you should put 5m. Always make sure you put units in physical calculations.
Ok I've been looking at Coloumb's law and it says k would be 9*10^9 N, is that right in this case because every time I do the math I get some other number from the answer I'm supposed to get.
 
Cglez1280 said:
9*10^9 N
Actually the unit is N m^2 / C^2.

Are the answers you got the same as the solution up to a power of 10?
 
Lucas SV said:
Actually the unit is N m^2 / C^2.

Are the answers you got the same as the solution up to a power of 10?
So the picture shows my work and the answer I'm supposed to get is 2.58*10^-2. I'm not sure what I did wrong
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    25 KB · Views: 648
  • #10
Cglez1280 said:
2.58*10^-2.
You made the mistake I thought you did. The charges are measured in micro coulombs, ##\mu C##. You forgot about the micro. Watch out those units.
 
Last edited:
  • #11
Lucas SV said:
You made the mistake I thought you did. The charges are measured in micro coulumbs - ##\mu C##. You forgot about the micro. Watch out those units.
Lucas SV said:
You made the mistake I thought you did. The charges are measured in micro coulumbs - ##\mu C##. You forgot about the micro. Watch out those units.
Hmm ok I see. But would the negative sign be dropped in my work because that seems to be an issue also. Another question is what would I do when I'm asked for the magnitude and direction of the net electric force on charge Q1?
 
  • #12
Cglez1280 said:
But would the negative sign be dropped in my work because that seems to be an issue also.
The negative sign is dropped precisely because question B asks for the magnitude of the force. The magnitude of a force is always non-negative, so you take the absolute value.
Cglez1280 said:
Another question is what would I do when I'm asked for the magnitude and direction of the net electric force on charge Q1?
I already explained magnitude. The direction can be seen from your free body diagram and can be found by the rule: opposite charges attract and like charges repel.
 
  • #13
Lucas SV said:
The negative sign is dropped precisely because question B asks for the magnitude of the force. The magnitude of a force is always non-negative, so you take the absolute value.

I already explained magnitude. The direction can be seen from your free body diagram and can be found by the rule: opposite charges attract and like charges repel.
Oh my god just when I get magnitude the last part completely lost me.
 
  • #14
Cglez1280 said:
Oh my god just when I get magnitude the last part completely lost me.
If the force is attractive, the force vector of charge 1 will be pointing towards charge 2. If the force is repulsive, the force vector of charge 1 will be pointing away from charge 2. The rule I just mentioned tells you if the force is attractive or repulsive.

Do you know what I meant by 'like' charges and 'opposite' charges?
 
  • #15
Lucas SV said:
If the force is attractive, the force vector of charge 1 will be pointing towards charge 2. If the force is repulsive, the force vector of charge 1 will be pointing away from charge 2. The rule I just mentioned tells you if the force is attractive or repulsive.

Do you know what I meant by 'like' charges and 'opposite' charges?
So basically my answer for Q1 will be positive and Q2 and Q3 will be negative?
Is there a certain equation I should I use to be able to get my answer?
 
  • #16
Cglez1280 said:
So basically my answer for Q1 will be positive and Q2 and Q3 will be negative?
The force on Q1 due to Q2 is positive because they attract and the coordinate of Q2 is higher than the coordinate Q1. This is in fact true regardless of how you choose to orient your x axis. If you choose to orient it to the right, Q2 will be to the right of Q1, and so will be the force on Q1 due to Q2. So the fact that the x-axis and the direction of the force have the same orientation makes the force positive. If instead you orient x to the left, Q2 will be to the left of Q1 (by definition of the position of Q1 and Q2).
Cglez1280 said:
Is there a certain equation I should I use to be able to get my answer?
It is the Coulomb law. The information about the direction of the force is contained in the law. Here is the equation for the coulomb force on ##q_1## due to ##q_2##, if ##q_1## is located at ##x_1## and ##q_2## is located at ##x_2##:
$$
F=k q_1 q_2 \frac{x_1-x_2}{|x_1-x_2|^3},
$$ where ##k## is the Coulomb's constant. It is easy to check that the magnitude of this equation yields what you probably used to compute the magnitude, while ##F## has the same direction obtained from the rules I gave.

The full law is actually written in terms of vectors in three dimensions. Note however that in your problem, the charges were collinear, which simplified the problem a lot, because you can neglect the extra dimensions and work in one dimension, by making sure that the x-axis intersects all three charges.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top