Drawing H-Bonded Structures: Dimers and Cyclics

  • Thread starter Thread starter MysticDude
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Drawing
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on drawing hydrogen-bonded structures for the (HF)2 dimer and the (CH3OH)4 cyclic structure. Participants express confusion about how to start the drawings, with one suggesting a method for visualizing the bonding in (HF)2. The conversation progresses to the cyclic structure of methanol, emphasizing the importance of including methyl groups attached to the oxygen atoms. There is also a brief mention of entropy related to the transition from dimers to larger cyclic structures, although the complexity of the topic is acknowledged. Overall, the thread highlights the collaborative effort to understand and visualize hydrogen bonding in these compounds.
MysticDude
Gold Member
Messages
142
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Draw each of the following H-bonded structure (a) (HF)2 dimer; (b) (CH3OH)4 cyclic.

Homework Equations


The Attempt at a Solution


I truly don't know where to begin. I started by searching about dimers and found a http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dimer_%28chemistry%29" but that confused me even more. Are the drawings supposed to be like the crystal structure of H2O?

Thanks for any help.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Well, H likes F so for (HF)2 put two H's around an F and put the other F in a position to bond to the same two H's in an identical fashion. Same thing goes for methanol but replace F with O... and stick a methyl group on the O's so that it doesn't interfere with the groovy coolness of the hydrogen bonding.
 
Wait so with (HF)2, would it be something like H--F~H--F? This is like [H--O--H]~[H--O--H].
 
Last edited:
No. Both F's must bond with both H's. It's not linear. Go in a more groovy direction...
 
So something like this(I hope the format stays):
H~~F
|...|
F~~H

This was the best way I could think of both Fs bonding with both Hs

Ignore the dots
 
Ohhhh! You found the groovy coolness! Nirvana!
 
AWESOME! Now onto (CH3OH)4 cyclic. This one will be hard to draw using the forum so I'll have to go to pictures, but I can use your help. I know how to draw the Lewis Structure, but I have no clue what cyclic is.

...H
...|
H--C--O--H
...|
...H
 
Just replace the F's with O's and add a methyl group to each O... dude!
 
Oh ok that's easy. But what is a cyclic though? I want to understand that! Oh and I am in no way trying to draw the Lewis Structure on the forum here lol. I mean I can but that would be annoying!
:D
 
  • #10
Once you make the dimer of methanol, you will notice that the H-O-H-O square is a cyclic containing only two methanol groups. Can you draw one that has 4?
 
  • #11
I'm thinking about it.
Would it be something like this?:
H~~O--H
|...~
|...O
|...|
|...H
|...~
O~~H--O

I understand that the diagram can be confusing, but I hope someone like you could understand me! Every O is connected to 2 H. I think that this would be correct.

:D
 
  • #12
And you think right.
 
  • #13
That's good enough for the forum but you need to add the methyl groups to the O's for the assignment that you turn in.

What do you think about the entropy of cyclics going from dimers to trimers to quadramers, etc...?
 
  • #14
chemisttree said:
That's good enough for the forum but you need to add the methyl groups to the O's for the assignment that you turn in.

What do you think about the entropy of cyclics going from dimers to trimers to quadramers, etc...?

Okay yeah I did that stuff for the problem. But your question is too complex as we have not studied that area in chemistry. I know what entropy is but your question is something that I have studied. But I thank you sooo much for helping me!

:D
 
Back
Top