Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the experiences and expectations of electrical engineering students and professionals regarding their field of study and potential career paths. Participants share insights on the nature of work in electrical engineering, particularly in relation to hands-on versus desk-based tasks, and express their interests in areas such as biomedical engineering, quantum mechanics, and opportunities at organizations like NASA and CERN.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Debate/contested
- Technical explanation
- Conceptual clarification
Main Points Raised
- One participant expresses disappointment with the desk-based nature of their internship at nVidia, seeking more hands-on experiences related to physics and engineering.
- Another participant notes that while many electrical engineers work at NASA and CERN, most of their tasks involve desk work, including design and simulation.
- Some suggest looking for companies that operate equipment, such as utilities or airlines, for more field engineering opportunities.
- There is a suggestion that working in biomedical engineering or with companies like Siemens and GE could provide valuable hands-on experience.
- A participant mentions that their senior design project did not directly translate to their current work in power engineering, emphasizing the importance of problem-solving skills learned in school.
- One engineer describes their role as an analog IC designer for applications in particle detection, highlighting the desk work involved but expressing enjoyment in their work.
- Several participants discuss the prevalence of software-based work in the electrical engineering field, particularly in companies like nVidia.
- There are inquiries about software tools used in circuit design and simulation, with links provided to various resources.
- A participant raises concerns about employment opportunities in biomedical and defense-related fields, particularly for non-citizens.
- Questions are posed regarding elective subjects for those interested in biomedical engineering and the feasibility of transitioning from electrical engineering to that field.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express a mix of experiences and expectations, with no consensus on the nature of work in electrical engineering. Some emphasize the desk-based reality of many roles, while others highlight the potential for hands-on work in specific industries. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best paths for those interested in more practical applications of their studies.
Contextual Notes
Participants mention various limitations, such as the dependence on specific job roles, the nature of different companies, and the challenges of entering certain fields based on citizenship requirements. There are also unresolved questions about the relevance of elective subjects for transitioning into biomedical engineering.
Who May Find This Useful
This discussion may be useful for current electrical engineering students, professionals considering a shift in their career focus, and individuals interested in the practical applications of electrical engineering in fields like biomedical engineering and physics.