The discussion centers on the electrochemical reduction of hydrogen (H2) to form hydrogen anions (H-), questioning the feasibility of the reaction and the role of solvents. Participants express skepticism about finding suitable solvents, noting that many polar solvents may react with hydride ions before hydrogen can be reduced. The potential for hydride ions to reduce organic compounds similarly to metal hydrides is also explored, with the consensus that while theoretically possible, practical limitations exist. Additionally, the importance of catalysts in facilitating the reaction and the necessity for reactions to occur at the electrode surface are highlighted. Overall, the conversation emphasizes the complexities and challenges in electrochemical hydrogen reduction.