Studying Electrodynamics and Classical Mechanics?

AI Thread Summary
Studying electrodynamics alongside classical mechanics is feasible, but the ability to manage both subjects effectively depends on individual aptitude, time availability, and the depth of understanding required. The exam in question, likely for the Physics Olympiad, necessitates knowledge at the Halliday/Resnick level for electrodynamics, which is more suitable for first-year undergraduates, rather than the upper-level Griffiths text. The discussion highlights the importance of pacing in learning, suggesting that attempting to cover advanced material too quickly may hinder comprehension. Overall, a balanced approach with a focus on foundational concepts is recommended for success in the exam.
Ujjwal Basumatary
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
I am preparing for an exam which requires me to solve problems in electrodynamics and electrostatics problems along with classical mechanics and geometrical optics problems. The concern is that I do not have electrodynamics in my course in school so I have to study it completely on my own. I bought 'Introduction to Electrodynamics' by D.J. Griffiths but before I begin studying sincerely for the exam, I want to ask if it is possible to simultaneously study electrodynamics with classical mechanics. Thank you.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Of course it is possible. The real question is if you can handle it and do well in both. This depends on what you define as doing well, how deep you need to go, how much time you have, and your aptitude for the subjects. It really is not something that can be answered by strangers on an internet forum.
 
Orodruin said:
Of course it is possible. The real question is if you can handle it and do well in both. This depends on what you define as doing well, how deep you need to go, how much time you have, and your aptitude for the subjects. It really is not something that can be answered by strangers on an internet forum.
I have scored well in the practice tests for the mechanics exams and am doing fine at the moment. I started learning about div, gradient and curl when this question popped in my mind. I am willing to work hard to become a better physicist :)
 
If six weeks ago you were just starting to learn vector calc and introductory E&M, I think it's extremely likely that you are going too fast to learn the material in any depth.

I read War and Peace in twenty minutes. It's about Russia.
 
Vanadium 50 said:
If six weeks ago you were just starting to learn vector calc and introductory E&M, I think it's extremely likely that you are going too fast to learn the material in any depth.

I read War and Peace in twenty minutes. It's about Russia.
Unfortunately, that is the problem. The exam I'm taking, which is due this November is intended for high school juniors, but I don't have any EM in my course this year. I'm having to learn it completely by myself.
 
Is this for the Physics Olympiad? (I suspect it is, based on your previous posts.) If so, does it really require Griffiths-level E&M (upper-level undergraduate), as opposed to Halliday/Resnick- or Young/Freedman-level (first-year undergraduate)?
 
Last edited:
jtbell said:
Is this for the Physics Olympiad? (I suspect it is, based on your previous posts.) If so, does it really require Griffiths-level E&M (upper-level undergraduate), as opposed to Halliday/Resnick- or Young/Freedman-level (first-year undergraduate)?
It requires Halliday/Resnick level electrodynamics.
 
Then Griffiths is above the level you want. In the US at least, students who use Griffiths have already taken a course on the level of Halliday/Resnick.
 
Ujjwal Basumatary said:
I am preparing for an exam which requires me to solve problems in electrodynamics and electrostatics problems along with classical mechanics and geometrical optics problems. The concern is that I do not have electrodynamics in my course in school so I have to study it completely on my own. I bought 'Introduction to Electrodynamics' by D.J. Griffiths but before I begin studying sincerely for the exam, I want to ask if it is possible to simultaneously study electrodynamics with classical mechanics. Thank you.

Ujjwal Basumatary said:
It requires Halliday/Resnick level electrodynamics.

Ujjwal Basumatary said:
I have scored well in the practice tests for the mechanics exams and am doing fine at the moment. I started learning about div, gradient and curl when this question popped in my mind. I am willing to work hard to become a better physicist :)

Based on that last quote, I think you are using a bazooka to kill a mosquito.

Zz.
 

Similar threads

Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
8K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top