How Does an Electron's Charge Avoid Repulsing Itself?

AI Thread Summary
An electron's charge does not repel itself because, in electrostatics, it is treated as a point charge, with its electric field being undefined at that point. This means an electron does not experience a force from its own electric field. The concept of an electron's size and whether it can be subdivided into smaller charges remains unresolved, particularly in quantum mechanics. While classical physics simplifies this issue, it raises questions about the fundamental nature of particles and forces. Ultimately, the mystery of why an electron doesn't explode from its own electric field suggests there may be deeper physics yet to be uncovered.
kye
Messages
166
Reaction score
2
An electron is so small, how does its charge avoid repulsing each other.. is there a unit of small charge or quanta wherein the charge doesn't repel.. or is there something akin to strong force like in atoms which avoid the protons from repulsing outward in the charge of the electron? What is the latest about this and what do you think is going on?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Good question... in electrostatics we just imagine the electron charge is at a single point, and then we say the electric field that results from that charge is undefined at that point (but exists everywhere else). In this way, an electron will never experience a force from its own electric field.

For any more detail than that, I think you need to go into the realms of quantum mechanics. I don't know the answer of what the size of an electron is, or if it really is a point, but I'm pretty sure that it is accurate to say that it is still an elementary particle, i.e. you cannot subdivide it into smaller charges that would end up repelling one another in the way that you describe. But who knows...
 
mikeph said:
Good question... in electrostatics we just imagine the electron charge is at a single point, and then we say the electric field that results from that charge is undefined at that point (but exists everywhere else). In this way, an electron will never experience a force from its own electric field.

How small is a "point" compared to say the Planck size in electrostatics? In quantum field theory, they have problem with this concept that is still unresolved (Giving rise to landau pole, renormalization, etc). But in electrostatics or classical physics, this is ignored or not mentioned. Is it because it is just approximation or the problem hidden? That is why we don't hear this mentioned in high school classes in the topic about electron and electron charge.. like the teacher saying that "the mystery is why the electron doesn't explode from experiencing it's own electric field due to the point being in single point of space and time unless there is new physics hidden underneath".

For any more detail than that, I think you need to go into the realms of quantum mechanics. I don't know the answer of what the size of an electron is, or if it really is a point, but I'm pretty sure that it is accurate to say that it is still an elementary particle, i.e. you cannot subdivide it into smaller charges that would end up repelling one another in the way that you describe. But who knows...
 
I was using the Smith chart to determine the input impedance of a transmission line that has a reflection from the load. One can do this if one knows the characteristic impedance Zo, the degree of mismatch of the load ZL and the length of the transmission line in wavelengths. However, my question is: Consider the input impedance of a wave which appears back at the source after reflection from the load and has traveled for some fraction of a wavelength. The impedance of this wave as it...
Back
Top