Electron spin? how?

  • #1
how actually electron and protons spin? explain me whether this spinning could provide torque to the positive charges then it means electrons and protons keeps rotating under their electrostatic field?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
ChrisVer
Gold Member
3,381
462
electrons are fundamental particles until today, so you can't really see them as spinning balls in order to give them that spin. In fact it's impossible to give it to them that way, since it would need them to spin faster than the speed of light (you know their spins, you know their radius boundary, so you can calculate the corresponding speed v, to find v>c).
under EM field, the spin itself spins around the Magnetic field...(spin transition)
 
  • #3
12,825
6,702
how actually electron and protons spin? explain me whether this spinning could provide torque to the positive charges then it means electrons and protons keeps rotating under their electrostatic field?

The electron doesn't spin in a Quantum Mechanical view but there is a component of its equation that resembles classical spin of an object and so its been named as such:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin_(physics [Broken])
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #4
jtbell
Mentor
15,764
4,006
how actually electron and protons spin?

They don't actually spin like a classical spinning ball, because they aren't actually little balls (or any other classical object). Nevertheless, they have "intrinsic angular momentum" which is a fundamental property like mass and charge. "Intrinsic angular momentum" is a mouthful to say all the time, so we say "spin" for short. This was probably an unfortunate choice because it confuses so many people. Nevertheless, this term is so deeply embedded in physics language that it's impossible to change now, so we have to live with it.
 
  • Like
Likes 100pawan%
  • #5
so what causes magnetic dipole moment in a ferromagnets?
 
  • #7
i just couldnt understand the language of wiki so could u please help me out!
 
  • #8
how an electron cant have a spin because they have an angular momentum i.e spin angular momentum then why?
 
  • #9
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
21,171
5,029
i just couldnt understand the language of wiki so could u please help me out!

Electrons usually pair up in their atomic and molecular orbitals. To do this, they have to have opposite spins (Typically called spin "up" and spin "down"). This cancels out the magnetic field from each of the electrons. But in certain materials, such as iron, one of the electrons isn't paired up, so nothing cancels its magnetic field. When this happens, the iron can become aligned so that the magnetic field of many of these electrons all add up and can generate a macroscopic magnetic field. This is where ferromagnetism comes from.

how an electron cant have a spin because they have an angular momentum i.e spin angular momentum then why?

In classical terms only spinning objects have angular momentum. That means that something must be spinning around an axis. However, for subatomic particles, this view is incorrect. For example, for an electron to be physically spinning around its axis fast enough to generate its magnetic field it would need to be spinning faster than the speed of light. Which is not possible. Instead it has intrinsic angular momentum, much like it has intrinsic mass, charge, etc.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person
  • #10
but actually i am saying can it be possible that the electrons through their spinning could provide a torque to the nearby particle like the protons or positive ions?
 
  • #11
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
21,171
5,029
but actually i am saying can it be possible that the electrons through their spinning could provide a torque to the nearby particle like the protons or positive ions?

I don't believe so.
 
  • #12
but how can spinning give rise to magnetism?explain me what is actually spin and how it give rise to magnetism i m little confused
 
  • #13
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
21,171
5,029
but how can spinning give rise to magnetism?explain me what is actually spin and how it give rise to magnetism i m little confused

I've already explained what spin is. But I'm afraid I can't explain the magnetism part. It looks to me like the magnetic field arises from having intrinsic angular momentum, but I'm not sure.
 
  • #14
but spin how canspin be the cause of magnetism i am not able to find it yet anywhere
 
  • #15
antell me whether here the magnetic field produced by electronis its electrostatic field only due to its charge or its a kind of another!!
 
  • #16
693
7
electrons are fundamental particles until today, so you can't really see them as spinning balls in order to give them that spin. In fact it's impossible to give it to them that way, since it would need them to spin faster than the speed of light (you know their spins, you know their radius boundary, so you can calculate the corresponding speed v, to find v>c).
under EM field, the spin itself spins around the Magnetic field...(spin transition)

This is actually a hugely quoted fallacy. If you use the relativistic expression for angular momentum there is a v < c for any R that gives the correct angular momentum. However v=c is really the only speed that makes sense, since you can't "slow down" an electrons spin, and I believe the radius you get by requiring J=hbar/2 is well over the experimental upper bound
 
  • #17
693
7
Sorry, to answer the OP: nobody really knows what spin is, but it acts like classical angular momentum in a lot of ways. That is, spin+angular momentum is conserved.

Currents produce magnetic fields, so classically speaking any charged object with angular momentum will have a magnetic field associated with it. Quantum spin also produced a magnetic field, although it is twice as strong as you would expect classically. Again, there is no generally accepted explanation of what is actually happening, but quantum field theory models it with incredible accuracy
 
  • #18
is it true in saying that a proton attracts the other electron due to its magnetic field because so far we had known through relativity that magnetic field is nothing but the electrostatic field?
 
  • #19
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
21,171
5,029
is it true in saying that a proton attracts the other electron due to its magnetic field because so far we had known through relativity that magnetic field is nothing but the electrostatic field?

No, the proton attracts the electron through its electric field. The magnetic and electric fields are combined into the Electromagnetic field, but it's still important to distinguish between which effect, electric or magnetic, is taking place.
 
  • #20
but on what account we can distinguish them both because both are due to the existence of their charges? according to me here electric and magnetic is although both same but given different names to avoid misconception in which we are presently suffering?
 
  • #21
but according to me spin just tells us whether the magnetic field produced will align with the magnetic field of others or just it gives its direction and the attraction or repulsion is based on charge,this is evident from seeing neutrons actually neutrons even have spin but no charge and also doesnt produce magnetic field? now tell me whether i am true or just give me some gud cause behind this spin?
 
  • #22
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
21,171
5,029
but on what account we can distinguish them both because both are due to the existence of their charges? according to me here electric and magnetic is although both same but given different names to avoid misconception in which we are presently suffering?

Electric and magnetic effects are different from each other and are given different names because of this. The difference between them is basic physics and you can find plenty of information on wikipedia and a million other places.

but according to me spin just tells us whether the magnetic field produced will align with the magnetic field of others or just it gives its direction and the attraction or repulsion is based on charge,this is evident from seeing neutrons actually neutrons even have spin but no charge and also doesnt produce magnetic field? now tell me whether i am true or just give me some gud cause behind this spin?

Again, spin is a term for the intrinsic angular momentum possessed by a particle and it does much more than give rise to a magnetic field. For one thing, it plays an integral part in determining whether particles are bosons or fermions.
 
  • #23
but in terms of magnetism you agree withmy point i have addressed here about spin or is there some more thing i need to get about spin in terms of magnetism?
 
  • #24
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
21,171
5,029
but in terms of magnetism you agree withmy point i have addressed here about spin or is there some more thing i need to get about spin in terms of magnetism?

I'm sorry, I can't understand your previous post well enough to know what point you were trying to make.
 
  • #25
(1) i was saying that spin is just the direction pointer of the produced magnetic field.
(2) it tells just whether the magnetic field produced will align with the magnetic field of others.
(3) this twofacts were evident from neutrons as neutrons have spin but no magnetic field.
 

Related Threads on Electron spin? how?

  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
19
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
11
Views
927
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
712
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
5K
Top