Is Jupiter's Great Red Spot a gas giant phenomenon or a solid core mystery?

AI Thread Summary
Jupiter's Great Red Spot is a feature of the gas giant, which is primarily composed of hydrogen and helium. The planet's core is believed to consist of metallic hydrogen and possibly a small rocky core, with extreme pressures preventing direct access to it. Hydrogen does not burn in the absence of oxygen, which is scarce on Jupiter, making the idea of lighting a match irrelevant. The planet's strong magnetic field indicates a solid core, and pressures increase significantly before reaching it. Overall, Jupiter presents a complex atmospheric structure that transitions from gas to liquid to solid.
Quadruple Bypass
Messages
120
Reaction score
0
Ive been wondering about this for a while. i read in the newspaper about jupiters new red spot, but anyways they mentioned that it was a gas planet. does this mean that if you were to fly to Jupiter and keep going, eventually you'd go right through it and out the other side? or is it so dense that the gas turns into a solid at the center?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
Well if you go at the right angle you might.But yes it is expected to be a mettallic hydrogen and there might be a small rocky core.
 
so, if you lit a match on a planet that was made out of flammable gas, it would just disappear? wow that sucks
 
Hydrogen requires oxygen to burn and there is very little of that on Jupiter.

Remember, Jupiter was hit by a comet (broken into many fragments) that exploded with an energy greater than all the nuclear weapons on Earth combined, and it is still there.
 
Quadruple Bypass said:
so, if you lit a match on a planet that was made out of flammable gas, it would just disappear? wow that sucks


Stop and think about what you just said.

First consider what 'burning' actually means(A chemical reaction between an oxidizer, of which there would be very little on jupiter, and a reactant, of which there is plenty in the form of hydrogen). Next consider that matter has to be conserved(so it doesn't make sense to talk about anything just 'disappearing').

As russ said:

Hydrogen requires oxygen to burn and there is very little of that on Jupiter.

Remember, Jupiter was hit by a comet (broken into many fragments) that exploded with an energy greater than all the nuclear weapons on Earth combined, and it is still there.
 
ah yes...i didnt know what actual gasses were on jupiter
 
BTW, if you DID fly your spaceship into Jupiter, you would never get anywhere near the metallic core. Pressures climb into the hundreds or even thousands of atmospheres long before that. There is speculation that it is one continuous gradient from gas to liquid to solid.
 
We know there is a solid metalic core because it has a strong,- very very, very strong magnetic field which makes big radiation belts around it.
And you could even get past a few of Jupiter's moons without this radiation zapping you to bits.
 
  • #10
Somewhere I remember seeing a profile of Jupiter's atmosphere, but I can't find the reference. It was based on Galileo descent into Jupiter at the end of the mission.

Meanwhile, here is some information on Jupiter:

Jupiter information
http://zebu.uoregon.edu/ph121/l15.html
http://abyss.uoregon.edu/~js/ast121/lectures/lec19.html

Jupiter atmosphere profile - based on Galileo measurements
http://wwwa.britannica.com/eb/article-54259

I think there is a better, more official atmosphere profile available from JPL.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top