Find all the different limits in + infinity

  • Thread starter Thread starter JPC
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Infinity Limits
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on finding the limits of the function f(x) = sqrt(ax^2 + 1) - x as x approaches positive infinity for different values of a. For a = 0, the limit approaches negative infinity, while for a < 0, there are no valid f(x) values as x approaches positive infinity. When a > 0, the limits vary: if a = 1, the limit is 0; if a > 1, the limit is positive infinity; and if 0 < a < 1, the limit is negative infinity. The participants also explore the implications of complex numbers for a < 0, concluding that the approach to limits varies significantly based on the value of a. Overall, the analysis emphasizes the importance of understanding the behavior of the function across different ranges of a.
JPC
Messages
204
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement



f(x) = sqroot(ax^2 + 1 ) - x

find all the different limits in + infinity that f can have with all the different "a" values

Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



i don't know if i did something wrong here :

- if a = 0 then f = 1 - x, limit : - infinty

- if a < 0 then no f value in + infinite
, (except if a = ' - 1 / +infnte', limit : - infinte)

- if a > 0 then

lim infinite ( f(x) ) = lim +infinite ( root (ax^2 . (1 + 1 / ax^2) ) - x )
= lim +infinte ( root(a) . x - x)
= lim +infinte ( (root(a) - 1) x)

so if a = 1, limit is 0
if a > 1 , limit is + infinity
if 0 < a < 1, limit is - infinity


PS ; if badly wrote, ect, I am sorry , but i was on a pc with a weird keyboard that really thrustrated me
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Can you explain "if a < 0 then no f value in + infinite"?

How do you go from "lim +infinite ( root (ax^2 . (1 + 1 / ax^2) ) - x )" to "lim +infinte ( root(a) . x - x)"?
 
hum

- considering the equation g(x) = ax² + 1
if a < 0, the, when x reaches +infinite, g(x) reaches -infinite
and since we only want to study f(x) in R , and not in complex numbers, we don't consider to be a value of f(x) when x reaches +infinite

(im not sure if you say 'reach' in english , but in french we call it 'tend vers')

- now if a > 0 :

lim + infinite ( f(x) )
= lim +infinite ( sqroot (ax^2 . (1 + 1 / ax^2) ) - x )

and

lim + infinite (1 + 1 / ax^2) = 1 + 0 = 1

so

lim +infinite ( sqroot (ax^2 . (1 + 1 / ax^2) ) - x )
= lim +infinite ( sqroot (ax^2 ) - x )
= lim +infinite ( sqroot(a)* x - x )
= lim +infinite ( (sqroot(a) -1 ) * x )

so if
(sqroot(a) -1 ) > 0
then
lim + infinite ( f(x) ) = +infinite

and if
(sqroot(a) -1 ) < 0
then
lim + infinite ( f(x) ) = -infinite

finding (sqroot(a) -1 ) = 0
sqroot(a) = 1
a = 1

so if
a>1
then
(sqroot(a) -1 ) > 0
lim + infinite ( f(x) ) = +infinite

and if
0<a<1
then
(sqroot(a) -1 ) < 0
lim + infinite ( f(x) ) = -infinite
 
and also :

its not in my program yet (will be in a few months) but is this true for a < 0 : ?

since
lim +oo(f(x)) = lim +infinite ( (sqroot(a) -1 ) * x )

a = -b , a<0

sqroot(-b) - 1 = i * sqroot(b) - 1

so lim +infinite ( (i* sqroot(b) -1 ) * x )

so lim +oo(f(x)) = (h, +oo)

- Now let's find that angle h :

r² = (-1)² + (root(b))² = b+1
r = root(b+1)
h = z + pi/2

by looking at the rectangular triangle of sides : 1, root(b), root(b+1) :

sin(z) = 1 / root(b+1)

z = sin^-1(1 / root(b+1))

so h = pi/2 + sin^-1(1 / root(b+1))

So when x-> +oo, and a<0 :
lim lim+oo (f(x) ) = (pi/2 + sin^-1(1 / root(b+1)) , +oo)


ok, i haven't worked at all with complex numbers atm, i just found that with the basic knowledge and understanding i have of complex numbers ( i = root(-1), i² = - 1, and the graphical represantation of complex numbers)

So , if i did anything wrong here, could you tell me please
 
im not sure if you say 'reach' in english , but in french we call it 'tend vers'
Approaches, tends toward (formal) or goes to (informal).
 
yes, but did i do any mistake in what i did ?

i mean did i use a wrong method , and just got lucky to get the right answer ? (i checked the limits with my calculator)
Because , what counts more in french schools is the way you find the answer rather than the answer itself
 
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...

Similar threads

Back
Top