Finding Angle in 3D using dot product

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a homework problem involving the geometry of a schooner's rigging, specifically focusing on determining the angle between rope BD and member CD, as well as the force projection on CD. Participants express confusion regarding the orientation of segment EF and the measurement of angle theta, suggesting that the problem may be poorly written due to missing information. One user mentions successfully calculating the necessary values after reconsidering the assumptions made about the angles. Another contributor notes that the problem's ambiguity leads to multiple valid solutions based on arbitrary assumptions. The overall consensus highlights the need for clearer problem statements in such scenarios.
KEØM
Messages
65
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement



Shown are a mast and a portion of the rigging of a schooner. Members CD and EF lie in the same plane, and CD is of length 7.5 m and forms an angle of 45° with a vertical line drawn through C. Knowing that when \theta = 45° the tension in rope BD is 250N, determine, (a) the angle between the rope BD and gaff CD, (b) the projection on CD of the force exerted by rope BD at point D.

Here is a link to a file sharing site with a picture of the problem. It is number 3.42 on the scanned page.

"[PLAIN problem3.42.pdf"]http://jumalafiles.info/showfile2-37705393236825434789501909625354498/problem342.pdf">download problem3.42.pdf[/URL]

Homework Equations


\vec{P}\bullet\vec{Q} = PQcos\theta

\vec{\lambda_{DC}}\bullet\vec{\lambda_{DB}} = cos\theta

where \vec{\lambda} is a unit position vector defining the rope portion DB and member DC in the problem.

The Attempt at a Solution



I found \vec{\lambda_{DC}} using the given angles but I cannot find \vec{\lambda_{DB}} with the given info. Any thoughts?

Thanks in advance,

KEØM
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
KEØM or anyone in the forum: I have a question about angle theta. The location of point E and F is unknown. Therefore, from the information given, we cannot assume segment EF is horizontal. Since angle theta is measured from an axis parallel to the x-axis passing through point E, and is measured to segment EF (EF being generally not horizontal), then angle theta generally cannot be a horizontal angle. Therefore, how do we know the orientation of skew angle theta? What am I missing? Or is problem 3.42 poorly written?
 
It is stated the the member CD makes an angle of 45 degrees with the vertical. So one can probably also assume that member EF makes a 45 degree angle with the vertical. However it does still seem poorly drawn.

It seems you can use T=250N along the entire rope to find DB

I will take a better look at it after class...
 
I did not even think about that nvn. I did the problem assuming that it was horizontal. I now have the solution if you are interested.

It is the second problem in the file:

"[URL title="download file from Jumala Files"]http://jumalafiles.info/showfile2-94156951958121615508614376973722952/hw5_solution.doc [/URL]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Problem 3.41 and 3.42 are written wrong. Consequently, there are infinite correct solutions, depending on what one arbitrarily (illogically) assumes for the missing information in the problem statement.
 
Back
Top