Finding Electric Flux of a Disc of Radius r

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the electric flux from a disc of radius r at a point also located at distance r from the center. Participants clarify that electric flux is defined for closed surfaces, making it inappropriate to discuss flux at a single point without a defined surface. The conversation shifts towards the electric field, emphasizing that if the point is a charged particle, the relevant calculation should focus on the electric field rather than flux. The correct approach would involve using Gauss's law, which states that the flux through a closed surface is proportional to the charge enclosed. Ultimately, the consensus is that the original question needs to be reformulated to address the correct concepts of electric field and flux.
prasum
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
a disc of radius r we have to find electric flux at a point which is at a distance r from the centre



i have used e=(sigma/2eo)(1-x/sqrt(r^2+x^2)) the area da=2pir*dr

i know flux=closed integral (e.da)
and x=r

after that what should i do
Reply With Quote
 
Physics news on Phys.org
r from the center in which direction? Is it along the axis? also since flux is a closed integral, flux at any point does not make sense. Electric field will be more appropriate...
 
ashishsinghal said:
r from the center in which direction? Is it along the axis? also since flux is a closed integral, flux at any point does not make sense. Electric field will be more appropriate...

yes it is along axis
 
you haven't answered whole of my question. Is it really flux what you are talking about as flux is for a closed surface.
Also if it was flux then since it is just a point with no charge by gauss law, flux would be zero.
It has to be field.
 
ashishsinghal said:
you haven't answered whole of my question. Is it really flux what you are talking about as flux is for a closed surface.
Also if it was flux then since it is just a point with no charge by gauss law, flux would be zero.
It has to be field.

the point is a charged particle
 
prasum said:
the point is a charged particle

is it a ring or a point charge?
flux or field?
if flux .. what is the surface?

please correct your question and post again ...


@ Ashish

how was your JEE?
 
cupid.callin said:
is it a ring or a point charge?
flux or field?
if flux .. what is the surface?

please correct your question and post again ...


@ Ashish

how was your JEE?

it is point charge
 
prasum said:
it is point charge

and flux
 
so what is the surface?>?

flux is always for a surface

anyway if you are asking for flux due to point charge on a spherical surface of radius r and centerd at the charge then its \frac{q}{\epsilon_o}
 
Back
Top