Finding the delta x of a bow and arrow pullback

  • Thread starter Thread starter Malcohmh
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Delta
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the delta x of a bow's pullback, with a pullback weight of 45 kg and an arrow speed of 184 mph (converted to 83 m/s). Participants debate the appropriate formulas to use, particularly concerning kinetic energy and work, while clarifying that the mass of the arrow is crucial for accurate calculations. The conversation reveals confusion over the application of spring energy formulas to bow mechanics, emphasizing that the bow's draw weight is not constant. Ultimately, a participant arrives at a distance of 0.61 meters for the pullback, but the accuracy of this result is questioned due to the complexities of bow dynamics. The discussion highlights the need for a deeper understanding of the physics involved in bow mechanics.
Malcohmh
Messages
5
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Find the delta x of the bow pullback. The weight of the pullback is 45 kg, the speed of the arrow as it shot out was 184mph( i converted that to velocity and got 83 m/s).

Homework Equations


I'm using K1+U1+W=K2+U2.

The Attempt at a Solution


I wasn't sure which formulas to plug into that equation... is it u1+work=k2? or work=k2. Then i didn't know what plugs into u1. work=FxD. please just show me where to start!
 
Physics news on Phys.org
So I ended up using work= kinectic energy, because it's the same. I got (444.8xDistance)=1/2(45.36)(82.6^2) then i got a very large distance? was that right?
 
Malcohmh said:
(444.8xDistance)=1/2(45.36)(82.6^2)
The arrow is 45.36kg?!
 
haruspex said:
The arrow is 45.36kg?!
No the pull on the bow! Sorry lol... Idk what I should plug in? Does that mean I have to solve for the mass in KE?
 
Malcohmh said:
No the pull on the bow! Sorry lol... Idk what I should plug in then
If you don't know the mass of the arrow then you cannot determine the KE achieved. Are you sure you have quoted the whole question, word for word?
 
haruspex said:
If you don't know the mass of the arrow then you cannot determine the KE achieved. Are you sure you have quoted the whole question, word for word?


Ya. I think I am missing some pieces.. from what I see towards the end of the video. :D
136 joules of KE= 1/2m(82.6^2). m=.04kg then i plug that into 444.8xDist.=1/2(.04)(82.06^2)! YES?! The pullback is .3m?!
 
Last edited:
Malcohmh said:
136 joules of KE= 1/2m(82.6^2). m=.04kg then i plug that into 444.8xDist.=1/2(.04)(82.06^2)! YES?! The pullback is .3m?!
Not quite. The 445 N is the peak draw weight. It will not be constant over the distance. Do you know the formula for PE of a spring?
 
It's (1/2)•444.8•Dist.=(1/2)(.04)(82.6^2)
Yes! Distance=.61meters!
 
Malcohmh said:
It's (1/2)•444.8•Dist.=(1/2)(.04)(82.6^2)
Yes! Distance=.61meters!
Are you saying that is the correct answer as given by the question setter?
There is a problem with applying the spring formula to drawing a bow. If we take the arc of the bow as behaving like a spring, the pull on the string does not. To do it more accurately, it would probably be simpler to think in terms of the movement of the ends of the bow, treating the arc as two rods jointed in the middle. When the two rods form an angle ##\pi-2\theta##, the torque at the joint is ##k\theta##. Knowing the draw length, with a bit of trig we can deduce the relationship between the draw weight (the max force applied to the string) and the max torque, and thus determine k. Then the stored energy would be ##\frac 12 k {\theta_{max}}^2##.
 
  • Like
Likes Malcohmh

Similar threads

Back
Top