Finding The magnitude of the velocity

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on calculating the magnitude of velocity using the equations V=Vi - (g*t) and d=Vi(t) + 1/2 a t^2. The participant initially calculated a velocity of 1.4 m/s but received feedback that their answer was incorrect, likely due to not specifying units and misunderstanding the formulas. Clarification was provided that the magnitude of velocity should be expressed as 4 m/s, with direction considered as well. The confusion arose from the use of positive and negative values for acceleration due to gravity, which is typically taken as negative when considering upward motion. Understanding the context and proper application of the formulas is essential for accurate calculations.
lesdayy
Messages
24
Reaction score
2
Homework Statement
i am 100% just lost.. i understand (somewhat) what it is asking but i cant seem to know which equatin to use to solve this problem?

Question asked: A ball is thrown upward with an initial velocity of 14 m/s. The approximate value of g = 10 m/s2. Take the upward direction to be positive. What is the magnitude and the direction of the velocity of the ball 1 second after it is thrown?
Relevant Equations
no sure which one to even use
i have tried V=Vi - (g*t) with an answer equals to 4
as well as
d=Vi(t) + 1/2 a t^2 with an answer equals to 19

my final asnwer was 1.43 and it was still wrong
i used formula a=v/t
v=14
t=10
i divided 14/10 to get 1.4
 

Attachments

  • new.PNG
    new.PNG
    9.2 KB · Views: 195
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
lesdayy said:
tried V=Vi - (g*t) with an answer equals to 4
Looks good, but you should always specify units. If this was flagged as wrong it suggests you have not entered the answer in the form expected.
It asks for "magnitude and direction", but tells you to take up as positive, which means simply answering "4m/s" should be fine. Hard to say more without seeing a screenshot of the question page and exactly what you entered.
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
Which of the two equations that you used gives a velocity?
How did you get 1.43 and what kind of beast is that? What are its units?
 
haruspex said:
Looks good, but you should always specify units. If this was flagged as wrong it suggests you have not entered the answer in the form expected.
It asks for "magnitude and direction", but tells you to take up as positive, which means simply answering "4m/s" should be fine. Hard to say more without seeing a screenshot of the question page and exactly what you entered.
 

Attachments

  • new.PNG
    new.PNG
    9.2 KB · Views: 158
Please show your work that led you to the answer of 1.4 m/s that you entered.
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
In post #1 you indicated that your first attempt was "4", not "1.4". If that was rejected, that's the screenshot I want to see.
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
kuruman said:
Please show your work that led you to the answer of 1.4 m/s that you entered.
i used formula a=v/t
v=14
t=10
i divided 14/10 to get 1.4
 
lesdayy said:
i used formula a=v/t
v=14
t=10
i divided 14/10 to get 1.4
I post #1 the formula you quoted was V=Vi - (g*t)
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
You are not looking for a, the acceleration, which is given as 10 m/s2. You are looking for the velocity at the end of the 1-second interval when the velocity at the beginning of the interval is 14 m/s.
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
  • #10
kuruman said:
You are not looking for a, the acceleration, which is given as 10 m/s2. You are looking for the velocity at the end of the 1-second interval when the velocity at the beginning of the interval is 14 m/s.
i understand what its asking, getting to the answer is the problem. is there a formula ?
 
  • #11
lesdayy said:
i understand what its asking, getting to the answer is the problem. is there a formula ?
Yes! The first one you quoted in post #1!
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
  • #12
haruspex said:
Yes! The first one you quoted in post #1!
V=Vi - (g*t) ?
 
  • #13
lesdayy said:
V=Vi - (g*t) ?
Yes. It's the only formula you have quoted which has a velocity as an answer.
 
  • Love
Likes lesdayy
  • #14
haruspex said:
Yes. It's the only formula you have quoted which has a velocity as an answer.
given that, the second question changed its time from 1 second to 2 seconds which gave me an answer of -6 and was still uncorrect :(
 
  • #15
i got it, thank yall VERY MUCH!
 
  • #16
lesdayy said:
i got it, thank yall VERY MUCH!
So what was going wrong?
 
  • #17
haruspex said:
So what was going wrong?
not knowing which formula to use!
 
  • #18
lesdayy said:
not knowing which formula to use!
I don't get it. In post #1 you wrote: "i have tried V=Vi - (g*t) with an answer equals to 4". Did you try 4m/s or not?
 
  • #19
lesdayy said:
not knowing which formula to use!
It's not that. It's understanding what the equations that you have are saying. An equation is a statement in the spoken language expressed in shorthand. For example, the equation ##v=v_i+at## replaces the following sentence in English: "The velocity at the end of a time interval ##t## is the same as the velocity at the beginning of the time interval to which one adds the acceleration multiplied by the time interval." If you can unfold the English behind the shorthand and if you know what the symbols stand for, it should be easy to figure out which equation matches the question that is asked.
 
  • Informative
Likes lesdayy
  • #20
haruspex said:
I don't get it. In post #1 you wrote: "i have tried V=Vi - (g*t) with an answer equals to 4". Did you try 4m/s or not?
so, with the system that is used for homework.. they only allow us to check our work once. i was trying out a couple of formulasbut i didnt know which one to use. although i did get the correct answer i wasnt aware that i even did. when i submitted my answer i went with 1.4 which is why i got it wrong to begin with
 
  • #21
kuruman said:
It's not that. It's understanding what the equations that you have are saying. An equation is a statement in the spoken language expressed in shorthand. For example, the equation ##v=v_i+at## replaces the following sentence in English: "The velocity at the end of a time interval ##t## is the same as the velocity at the beginning of the time interval to which one adds the acceleration multiplied by the time interval." If you can unfold the English behind the shorthand and if you know what the symbols stand for, it should be easy to figure out which equation matches the question that is asked.
i just did a two chapters on average speed, distance, instanteneous speed, motion etc etc and i was able to understand the question asked and know whixh formula to use. for some reason something is just not clicking for this chapter, there are a few different words used to describe thesame thing and its throwing me off "(
 
  • #22
lesdayy said:
i just did a two chapters on average speed, distance, instanteneous speed, motion etc etc and i was able to understand the question asked and know whixh formula to use. for some reason something is just not clicking for this chapter, there are a few different words used to describe thesame thing and its throwing me off "(
Your actions belie your claims. By your admission, you obtained the wrong answer of 1.4 m/s from the equation ##v=\dfrac{v_i}{g}## which is incorrect on many grounds. You also stated in post #1 that you don't know which formula to use. That's OK, we are here to help you sort things out.

Your difficulties may very well originate in your statement "##\dots## there are a few different words used to describe thesame thing and its throwing me off." What are the different words and what same thing are they describing? Maybe that is where your confusion with this chapter lies.
 
  • #23
Whenever you have a problem like this, you should always write down what you know,
For example they gave you the initial velocity, the acceleration and time.
Write it down something like this with the correct units
u = 14ms-1
a = -10ms-2
t = 1s

From there if you look at motion formulae, there's one that fits perfectly to give us v, that is
v = u + at
So substitute values to give you this
v = 14 + (-10 x 1)
= 14 - 10
= 4ms-1
I should note that ms-1 is the exact same as m/s, just different notation.
Edit: Oh also, seeing as it's asking for direction, you could either leave it as a positive or also include the direction at the end of the statement, for example
4ms-1 upwards
2nd Edit: You should also note that gravity will always be a downwards acceleration, hence when the ball is going up, the gravity should be having a negative impact on it. You used the displacement formula to figure out displacement, where displacement should've been done like this:
s = ut + 1/2 x a x t2
= (14 x 1) + (0.5 x (-10) x 12)
= 14 - 5
= 9

You've done it so acceleration is positive to give you 14m.
 
Last edited:
  • #24
lesdayy said:
so, with the system that is used for homework.. they only allow us to check our work once. i was trying out a couple of formulasbut i didnt know which one to use. although i did get the correct answer i wasnt aware that i even did. when i submitted my answer i went with 1.4 which is why i got it wrong to begin with
This is one reason for keeping track of units.
"i divided 14/10 to get 1.4"
Becomes
"i divided ##14m/s## by ##10m/s^2## to get ##1.4s##". Do you see that?
##\frac{\frac ms}{\frac m{s^2}}=s##.
So then you would have realized you were not getting a velocity. (You got the time until the velocity would be zero.)

But perhaps the more important point is that plugging data into random formulas is not a recipe for success. There is no point in knowing a formula unless you understand what the variables represent and in what context the formula applies.
In the case of ##v=v_i-gt##, it is saying that if a vertical velocity (measured upwards) is modified by gravity over time t then it is reduced by gt.
The usual form is the more general ##v_f=v_i+at##, where a is an arbitrary constant acceleration measured in the same direction as the velocities.
 
  • #25
kuruman said:
Your actions belie your claims. By your admission, you obtained the wrong answer of 1.4 m/s from the equation ##v=\dfrac{v_i}{g}## which is incorrect on many grounds. You also stated in post #1 that you don't know which formula to use. That's OK, we are here to help you sort things out.

Your difficulties may very well originate in your statement "##\dots## there are a few different words used to describe thesame thing and its throwing me off." What are the different words and what same thing are they describing? Maybe that is where your confusion with this chapter lies.
with this specific question, its asking for the The magnitude of the velocity which in other words makes me believe that its not just asking for velocity but for something else. as well as g+10m/s^2 also being the same thing as acceleration in some formulas like Vf=Vi +at
 
  • #26
Velocity is a vector, it has magnitude and direction. The magnitude of the velocity is also known as "speed". For example, the magnitude of the initial velocity (or the initial speed) is 14 m/s and the direction is "up". You have to find the speed at the end of the 1-second interval and the direction which could be "up" or "down". The problem is exactly asking you to find the final velocity vector and is providing you with two boxes: one for the magnitude (or speed) and one for the direction.
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
  • #27
nickbb12 said:
Whenever you have a problem like this, you should always write down what you know,
For example they gave you the initial velocity, the acceleration and time.
Write it down something like this with the correct units
u = 14ms-1
a = -10ms-2
t = 1s

From there if you look at motion formulae, there's one that fits perfectly to give us v, that is
v = u + at
So substitute values to give you this
v = 14 + (-10 x 1)
= 14 - 10
= 4ms-1
I should note that ms-1 is the exact same as m/s, just different notation.
Edit: Oh also, seeing as it's asking for direction, you could either leave it as a positive or also include the direction at the end of the statement, for example
4ms-1 upwards
can you explain why they are using g = -10 m/s2 when they are saying its g = 10 m/s2 ?
 
  • #28
Gravity is ~9.8ms-2 or in your case they simplify this to 10ms-2
The reason gravity is negative is because of the direction of the ball. Since we are considering upwards to have a positive velocity and downwards to have a negative velocity, if gravity has a downward nature, then it should be negative. If we were to try it with positive acceleration we would have this:
u = 14ms-1
t = 1s
a = 10ms-2
v = u + at
= 14 + 10 x 1
= 24ms-1
Now somethings wrong? The velocity increased upwards even though gravity was affecting it?
In order for this to be true, gravity on Earth would have to flip. So we write acceleration/gravity as negative, assuming that an upwards velocity is positive.
An easy way to understand it is that up is positive, down is negative. If gravity pulls things down then it has to be negative.

You can actually flip it around so up is negative and down is positive, like for example when skydiving you wouldn't say "My velocity is -100ms-1, because that's wrong given the situation, in a situation where you throw a ball up, you want its upward motion to be positive and its downward motion to be negative. Hope this helped if you had any more questions let me know! :)
 
Last edited:
  • #29
nickbb12 said:
Gravity is ~9.8ms-2 or in your case they simplify this to 10ms-2
The reason gravity is negative is because of the direction of the ball. Since we are considering upwards to have a positive velocity and downwards to have a negative velocity, if gravity has a downward nature, then it should be negative. If we were to try it with positive acceleration we would have this:
u = 14ms-1
t = 1s
a = 10ms-2
v = u + at
= 14 + 10 x 1
= 24ms-1
Now somethings wrong? The velocity increased upwards even though gravity was affecting it?
In order for this to be true, gravity on Earth would have to flip. So we write acceleration/gravity as negative, assuming that an upwards velocity is positive.
An easy way to understand it is that up is positive, down is negative. If gravity pulls things down then it has to be negative.
so when using g = 10 m/s2 the 10 would always be negative ? or depends on the direction its going ?

the second part of that question is t=2
my answer ended up being negative but the correct answer is positive
 

Attachments

  • thumbnail_IMG_3460.jpg
    thumbnail_IMG_3460.jpg
    44 KB · Views: 133
  • #30
lesdayy said:
so when using g = 10 m/s2 the 10 would always be negative ?
'g' is defined as the magnitude of the acceleration at Earth's surface, so it is always positive.
Whether g or -g is used in the equation depends what has been chosen as the positive direction. Normally one chooses the same direction as positive for all displacements, velocities, accelerations and forces. For vertical motion (on Earth's surface) up is generally chosen as positive, making the equation ##v_f=v_i-gt##.
lesdayy said:
my answer ended up being negative but the correct answer is positive
It asks for magnitude and direction, filled in separately. A magnitude is never negative. For a scalar, magnitude is just the absolute value. So the form of the answer is 6m/s, downwards.
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
  • #31
And in the shorthand notation of physics, -6 m/s stands for "a speed of six meters per second directed downwards". If you take -6 m/s apart, the negative sign replaces "directed downwards", 6 replaces "six" and m/s replaces "meters per second".
 
  • #32
kuruman said:
And in the shorthand notation of physics, -6 m/s stands for "a speed of six meters per second directed downwards". If you take -6 m/s apart, the negative sign replaces "directed downwards", 6 replaces "six" and m/s replaces "meters per second".
how come both answers are postive when one is upward and the other is negative on the websites hw? what youre saying totally makes sense
 
  • #33
lesdayy said:
how come both answers are postive when one is upward and the other is negative on the websites hw? what youre saying totally makes sense
It's what "magnitude" means. The magnitude of a number is also known as its absolute value. The magnitude of 2 is 2, the magnitude of -2 is 2.
The magnitude of a velocity is the speed, which is always zero or positive and independent of direction.
 
  • #34
haruspex said:
It's what "magnitude" means. The magnitude of a number is also known as its absolute value. The magnitude of 2 is 2, the magnitude of -2 is 2.
The magnitude of a velocity is the speed, which is always zero or positive and independent of direction.
great :')
you have been very helpful! thank ypu sooooooooooo much
 
  • #35
haruspex said:
It's what "magnitude" means. The magnitude of a number is also known as its absolute value. The magnitude of 2 is 2, the magnitude of -2 is 2.
The magnitude of a velocity is the speed, which is always zero or positive and independent of direction.
one more question. when the problem given gives you "a= −10 m/s2" instead of " a= 10 m/s2" the difference is just plugging the number in as a negative ? i know the negative is just direction but as far as putting into an equation it'll be negative ?
 
  • #36
lesdayy said:
one more question. when the problem given gives you "a= −10 m/s2" instead of " a= 10 m/s2" the difference is just plugging the number in as a negative ? i know the negative is just direction but as far as putting into an equation it'll be negative ?
example "Free fall v=vi+at, a= -10 m/s2 , if up is chosen as positive direction of axis" does that mean if the quesyion is saying downward or upward use -10 or +10 ?
 
  • #37
If the problem specifies which direction is positive, then any magnitude of a vector that is along that direction requires a "+" sign in front of it and any magnitude of a vector that is opposite to that direction requires a "-" sign in front of it. If the problem does not specify which direction is positive, you are free to choose but you must be clear which direction is positive.

In this specific problem, you are told to take the upward direction as positive. Since up is opposite to down, and the direction of the acceleration is down, then the acceleration vector is given by ##a=-g=-10~\text{m/s}^2##. The initial velocity is up and is given by ##v_i=+14~\text{m/s}##. With this choice, the equation for the velocity is $$v=v_i+at=14~\text{m/s}+(-10~\text{m/s}^2)t.$$ After 1 s has elapsed, the velocity is ##v=14~\text{m/s}+(-10~\text{m/s}^2)\times 1~\text{s}=4~\text{m/s}.## The absence of the negative sign says that the velocity is still up whilst the speed has been reduced to 4 m/s.

Now consider this. Suppose the problem told you to take the down direction as positive. Then what? The equation to use is still the same, ##v=v_i+at##. However, the acceleration which is down points in the positive direction, so we substitute in the equation ##a=+g=+10~\text{m/s}^2.## Likewise, the initial velocity is up which is opposite to the direction that we are told is positive. Therefore the initial velocity vector is ##v_i=-14~\text{m/s}##. Putting this in the equation gives $$v=v_i+at=-14~\text{m/s}+(+10~\text{m/s}^2)t.$$ After 1 s has elapsed, the velocity is ##v=-14~\text{m/s}+(+10~\text{m/s}^2)\times 1~\text{s}=-4~\text{m/s}.## The presence of the negative sign says that the velocity is opposite to our chosen positive direction of down, i.e. it is up. Also, the speed has been reduced to 4 m/s.

The moral of the story is that, regardless of which way you choose the positive direction for the vectors and if you are careful with your substitutions, after 1 s the ball will be moving in the same direction as initially and with a reduced speed of 4 m/s. See how it works?
 
  • Informative
Likes lesdayy
  • #38
kuruman said:
In this specific problem, you are told to take the upward direction as positive
but it said "IF"
 
  • #39
lesdayy said:
but it said "IF"
Where? According to your post #1
lesdayy said:
Question asked: A ball is thrown upward with an initial velocity of 14 m/s. The approximate value of g = 10 m/s2. Take the upward direction to be positive. What is the magnitude and the direction of the velocity of the ball 1 second after it is thrown?
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy
  • #40
lesdayy said:
if up is chosen as positive direction of axis
i was reffering to the question i had just asked, not the OG
 
  • #41
If you mean this question,
lesdayy said:
example "Free fall v=vi+at, a= -10 m/s2 , if up is chosen as positive direction of axis" does that mean if the quesyion is saying downward or upward use -10 or +10 ?
I thought I answered it in post #37. Maybe I didn't understand what you are asking. What are you asking? Please explain.
 
  • #42
lesdayy said:
example "Free fall v=vi+at, a= -10 m/s2 , if up is chosen as positive direction of axis" does that mean if the quesyion is saying downward or upward use -10 or +10 ?
If you choose up as positive and the acceleration is 10##m/s2## downward then you write the equation as v=vi-10t.
What two options are you suggesting for what the question says? Please explain in more detail.
 
  • #43
kuruman said:
If you mean this question,

I thought I answered it in post #37. Maybe I didn't understand what you are asking. What are you asking? Please explain.
haruspex said:
If you choose up as positive and the acceleration is 10##m/s2## downward then you write the equation as v=vi-10t.
What two options are you suggesting for what the question says? Please explain in more detail.
its just another question that partains to this
kuruman said:
its just another question that partains to og question. "Free fall. v=vi+at, a=−10m/s2, if up is chosen as positive direction of axis" it said IF... does that mean we chose + or - or ? I am not sure what the if means when given
 
  • #44
lesdayy said:
its just another question that partains to og question. "Free fall. v=vi+at, a=−10m/s2, if up is chosen as positive direction of axis" it said IF... does that mean we chose + or - or ?
Yes. If you choose down as positive then a=+10m/s2. But that choice reverses the signs of the velocities too, so if it is something thrown up at 5m/s then we have v=-5+10t, and a positive result means a downward velocity.
 
  • Like
Likes lesdayy

Similar threads

Back
Top