Griffiths Introduction to Electrodynamics (Stokes Theorem Corollary)

7 replies · 3K views · last reply
cemtu
Messages
99
Reaction score
7
Homework Statement
Electrodynamics, Stokes Theorem
Relevant Equations
No Equations needed
Although Stokes Theorem says that the line integral of a closed surface equals to zero why do we get a non-zero value out of this question 1.11 (and figure 1.33) in the Griffits Introduction to Eletrodynamics Book?
Textbook page 35, section 1.3 Integral Calculus, showing Figure 1.31 and Figure 1.32, Corollary 2 circled in red, and Example 1.11 with Figure 1.33: a square surface in the x-y-z plane with edges labeled (i) through (iv).
Textbook page from Griffiths Electrodynamics showing Stokes theorem worked example with four line-integral segments (i) to (iv) and their sum 1 + 4/3 - 1 + 0 = 4/3, plus Problem 1.34 and Figure 1.35 of a cube.
 
Orodruin said:
It is not an integration over a closed surface.
It is an integration over a closed rectangle shape
 
cemtu said:
It is an integration over a closed rectangle shape
The rectangle is not a closed surface. The definition of a closed surface is that it has no boundary. The rectangle clearly has a boundary - the four straight lines that form its border.
 
Orodruin said:
The rectangle is not a closed surface. The definition of a closed surface is that it has no boundary. The rectangle clearly has a boundary - the four straight lines that form its border.
sir there is nothing without boundaries and borders, so how exactly this second corollary of stokes theorem has a proper use in physics?
 
cemtu said:
sir there is nothing without boundaries and borders, so how exactly this second corollary of stokes theorem has a proper use in physics?
This is wrong. For example, the two-dimensional sphere has no boundary curve.
 
Orodruin said:
This is wrong. For example, the two-dimensional sphere has no boundary curve.
sir, spheres are three-dimensional objects.
 
cemtu said:
sir, spheres are three-dimensional objects.
You are thinking of a ball or the fact that the sphere is embedded in three-dimensional space. The sphere is the two-dimensional boundary of a three-dimensional ball. The boundary of an n-dimensional object is (n-1)-dimensional. In order to know where you are on a sphere you need two coordinates (eg, longitude and latitude), this makes the sphere two-dimensional.