Help Needed: Rewriting Covariant Derivative to Killing Equations

trv
Messages
72
Reaction score
5
A little stuck while working through a derivation. Hope someone can help.

Homework Statement



Starting from

<br /> -\xi^c(\Gamma^d_{ca}g_{db}+\Gamma^d_{cb}g_{ad})+\partial_b\xi^dg_{ad}+\partial_a\xi^cg_{cb}=0<br />

I need to obtain the Killing equations, i.e.

<br /> \bigtriangledown_b\xi_a+\bigtriangledown_a\xi_b=0<br />

Homework Equations



The Attempt at a Solution



Working backwards...

Rewriting the covariant derivative in terms of the partial derivative gives

<br /> \bigtriangledown_b\xi_a+\bigtriangledown_a\xi_b=\partial_a\xi_b+\partial_b\xi_a-\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c=0<br />

Lowering the vector in the partial derivatives gives...

<br /> \partial_a\xi_b+\partial_b\xi_a-\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c=-\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c+\partial_b\xi^dg_{ad}+\partial_a\xi^cg_{cb}=0<br />

I don't however know how to go from

<br /> -\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c

to

<br /> -\xi^c(\Gamma^d_{ca}g_{db}+\Gamma^d_{cb}g_{ad})

Can someone help?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
trv said:
A little stuck while working through a derivation. Hope someone can help.

Homework Statement



Starting from

<br /> -\xi^c(\Gamma^d_{ca}g_{db}+\Gamma^d_{cb}g_{ad})+\partial_b\xi^dg_{ad}+\partial_a\xi^cg_{cb}=0<br />

I need to obtain the Killing equations, i.e.

<br /> \bigtriangledown_b\xi_a+\bigtriangledown_a\xi_b=0<br />

Homework Equations



The Attempt at a Solution



Working backwards...

Rewriting the covariant derivative in terms of the partial derivative gives

<br /> \bigtriangledown_b\xi_a+\bigtriangledown_a\xi_b=\partial_a\xi_b+\partial_b\xi_a-\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c=0<br />

Lowering the vector in the partial derivatives gives...

<br /> \partial_a\xi_b+\partial_b\xi_a-\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c=-\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c+\partial_b\xi^dg_{ad}+\partial_a\xi^cg_{cb}=0<br />

I don't however know how to go from

<br /> -\Gamma^c_{ba}\xi_c-\Gamma^c_{ab}\xi_c

to

<br /> -\xi^c(\Gamma^d_{ca}g_{db}+\Gamma^d_{cb}g_{ad})

Can someone help?

its a little difficult to show. first you should replace Xi with Xi*metric, then use this metric to lower the index on Gamma, then replace this Gamma with Gamma*metric, which is what we want. hopefully that makes some sense.
 
Thanks, it does make sense.

<br /> \xi^c\Gamma^d_{ca}g_{bd}=\xi_eg^{ce}\Gamma^d_{ca}g_{bd}=\xi_eg^{ce}\Gamma_{bca}=\xi_e\Gamma^e_{ba}=\xi_c\Gamma^c_{ba}<br />
 
There are two things I don't understand about this problem. First, when finding the nth root of a number, there should in theory be n solutions. However, the formula produces n+1 roots. Here is how. The first root is simply ##\left(r\right)^{\left(\frac{1}{n}\right)}##. Then you multiply this first root by n additional expressions given by the formula, as you go through k=0,1,...n-1. So you end up with n+1 roots, which cannot be correct. Let me illustrate what I mean. For this...
Back
Top