Help with Newton's Problem | Get Assistance Here

  • Thread starter Thread starter abc
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Newtons
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around solving a physics problem involving Newton's laws and friction. A user seeks clarification on how to determine the force required to maintain a constant velocity for two objects, given their weights and the coefficient of friction. The calculations indicate that the frictional force and tension in the rope must be balanced to achieve constant velocity. After analyzing the forces, it is concluded that the book's provided answer of 4.05 Newtons is incorrect, with a corrected calculation yielding 5.67 Newtons. The conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding the forces acting on the objects to solve the problem accurately.
abc
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
can anyone help me in this problem ?
see the attachment please
 

Attachments

  • untitled1.jpg
    untitled1.jpg
    8.9 KB · Views: 407
Physics news on Phys.org
a = 5.4 Newton >>>> i think it is not clear in the attachment ?
 
This problem sounds a bit tricky, but it really isn't. What they aren't telling you is that first you'll pull the box with whatever force you need to get it moving. Once you've done that it wants to know what force keeps it at a constant velocity.

Using Newton's laws, what force on an object produces a constant velocity?

If you will answer that I'll help with the rest of the problem.
 
The total weight of the objects is 9.0 Newtons. Since the coefficient of friction is 0.35, the friction force will be (0.35)(9.0) Newtons. The force necessary to keep them moving at constant velocity is exactly the force necessary to offset that.
 
thanx HallsofIvy ... but the answer written in the book is 4.05 ( but i don't know the steps to bring this answer )
dear locrian... do u mean this >>>> sum F= 0 ?
thanx guys ... but please continue to solve this problem
 
Either you've been given insufficient information, or your book has an incorrect solution.
Let's look at the forces working on each object A, B in the horizontal direction
Object A:
1. The frictional force from the ground, -f_{G}
2. The frictional force between A and B:-f_{AB}
3. the rope tension: -T
4. The force you drag the along system with: f
Object B:
1. The frictional force between A and B:f_{AB}
2. the rope tension:-T
(I've added signs for assumed directions)

Are you with me on this?
 
HallsofIvy, there's also friction between the blocks (I would imagine - maybe with the same coefficient).

But assuming that, I get F= 4.4N

abc, draw the free-body force diagram, and take it from there.
 
We'll proceed:
The weight of object B is w_{B}, and we have therefore:
f_{AB}=\mu_{AB}w_{B}
where \mu_{AB} is the friction coefficient between A and B

That A moves with constant velocity implies that B also moves with constant velocity, since otherwise, the rope length can't remain constant.

Hence, the rope tension must satisfy (by Newton's 2.law applied to object B in the horizontal direction):
T=\mu_{AB}w_{B}

Clearly, the normal force from the ground on object A must balance the weights of both objects; hence we have for the frictional force:
f_{G}=\mu_{G}(w_{A}+w_{B})

Newton's 2.law in the horizontal direction for object A must read:
f-f_{AB}-T-f_{G}=0
Or, solving for f:
f=\mu_{G}w_{A}+(\mu_{G}+2\mu_{AB})w_{B}
By setting \mu_{G}=\mu_{AB}=0.35 we gain:
f=0.35*(5.4+3*3.6)=0.35*16.2=5.67

your book's solution is wrong
 
Last edited:
thanx all for replying ...
regard
abc
 
Back
Top