Historical: Mechanized cutting of stone vs. concrete

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the historical use of machine-cut stone compared to concrete in construction. It highlights that while ancient cultures like the Romans and Egyptians utilized mortar and hand-cut stone, the advent of structural concrete is attributed to 19th-century France. Participants note that machine-cut marble was used by the Romans for decorative purposes, suggesting some early use of mechanization in stone cutting. The conversation raises questions about the prevalence of machine-cut stone in other cultures and its transition to modern materials like concrete and steel. Overall, the thread explores the evolution of stone cutting techniques and their applications in structural engineering.
Breeze
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hello.

I've just found this forum as I am looking for an answer to a question. For what it's worth, by way of introduction, I am a software and telephony engineer, with interests in aviation, boat design, and energy-efficient houses. I also write when I can.

Here's my question.

Plenty of ancient and old structures use cut stone structurally. The Romans (and, I have found with a quick Google) the Egyptians used mortar as a bonding agent, to extend the capabilities of stone and fired brick (fired brick being an Indian invention of about 3000 BC).

Structural concrete seems to be a 19th-century French invention, and (along with steel) is the usual material for large structures today.

My question is: Was there ever a culture that used machine-cut stone much? Or did everyone go from natural (or hand-cut) structural stone, to structural concrete and steel, with fired brick for smaller structures? I can't even think of an example of a structure that used machine-sawn stone.

Thanks.
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
i sell coordinate measurement machines made in Germany..they are made with granite that is mecahnically cut then ground and hand lapped to microns flatness..many components of structures use granite,,all are cut with a diamond rope saw to rough dimensions and machined to tight tolerances..
 
Aberdeen the granite city
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b00ml5wx/Jonathan_Meades_Off_Kilter_Episode_1/
About 20 minutes in he goes on about cutting the granite.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Breeze said:
My question is: Was there ever a culture that used machine-cut stone much?
The romans had machine cut marble. It's fairly simple to just mount a few saw blades in a frame and move it back-forth with a treadmill.
It was probably to get uniform thin sheets of marble for decorative use.
 
Thread 'Where is my curb stop?'
My water meter is submerged under water for about 95% of the year. Today I took a photograph of the inside of my water meter box because today is one of the rare days that my water meter is not submerged in water. Here is the photograph that I took of my water meter with the cover on: Here is a photograph I took of my water meter with the cover off: I edited the photograph to draw a red circle around a knob on my water meter. Is that knob that I drew a red circle around my meter...
Hi all, i have some questions about the tesla turbine: is a tesla turbine more efficient than a steam engine or a stirling engine ? about the discs of the tesla turbine warping because of the high speed rotations; does running the engine on a lower speed solve that or will the discs warp anyway after time ? what is the difference in efficiency between the tesla turbine running at high speed and running it at a lower speed ( as fast as possible but low enough to not warp de discs) and: i...
Back
Top