I How can I have an image in space that I cannot reach out and feel with my hand?

  • I
  • Thread starter Thread starter barryj
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    hand Image Space
AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around a science gadget utilizing two parabolic mirrors to create an image of an object placed below one mirror, which appears to hover above the hole in the top mirror. Participants clarify the optical principles involved, distinguishing between "virtual objects" and "real images," with the image above the device being classified as a real image. A ray diagram is suggested to illustrate how light rays converge and diverge, creating the illusion of an object in space. There is also a mention of confusion regarding the terminology used in optics, particularly concerning ray intersections and image formation. The conversation highlights the intriguing nature of optical illusions and the challenges in accurately describing them.
barryj
Messages
856
Reaction score
51
There is this science gadget that consists of two parobolic mirrors, one with a hole in it and you place an item in the bottom of one, turn the other mirror with the hole on top of it, and you can see the image of the item standing above the hole in the top mirror. How is this done? Are the mirrors parobolic, I am not sure. What does the focul length have to be. I do not know of any other way that I can see an image but when I try to touch it, it is not there. Explanation Please
 
  • Like
Likes berkeman
Astronomy news on Phys.org
It would be interesting to see a ray diagram showing how this works.
 
barryj said:
It would be interesting to see a ray diagram showing how this works.

The diagram they have in phinds' link shows two rays emerging from the object and converging at a point just above the device. These rays (and all the others from the rest of the object) pass right through each other and start to diverge. These rays diverge the same way that rays from a real object diverge and when you put your eye into their path the rays appear to be coming from an object hovering in air (because that's the closest point the rays are diverging from).

This imaginary object is known as a 'virtual object' in optics terminology.
 
Drakkith said:
This imaginary object is known as a 'virtual object' in optics terminology.

If by "imaginary object" you mean the image that is hovering above the device, then that is not a "virtual object." It is a "real image."
 
pixel said:
If by "imaginary object" you mean the image that is hovering above the device, then that is not a "virtual object." It is a "real image."

Whoops, you appear to be correct.
 
pixel said:
If by "imaginary object" you mean the image that is hovering above the device, then that is not a "virtual object." It is a "real image."
Okay, upon reviewing my class notes I figured out why I was confused. The example in my notes has a marginal and a chief ray intersecting and then being intercepted by a lens before they could form an image, thus forming a virtual object on the right side of the lens. I thought it was two chief rays or two marginal rays or something.
 
Off course the annoying part of these gadgets is that the object always hovers just below the hole, not above it.
 
Back
Top