How do hydrogen and oxygen mix?

  • Thread starter Thread starter tackyattack
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Hydrogen Oxygen
AI Thread Summary
Mixing hydrogen and oxygen in a bottle results in diffusion, leading to a homogeneous mixture over time. The gases do not separate based on their densities when the bottle is upright; instead, they remain intermixed due to their gaseous state. If the bottle is turned upside down and uncapped, both gases would escape rather than separating by weight. Ignition is required to form water from the mixture, and even minimal energy can trigger a reaction. The behavior of the gases is independent of the bottle's orientation, as gravity does not affect their mixing at the molecular level.
tackyattack
Messages
56
Reaction score
0
So I'm curious, if you mix two parts hydrogen and one part oxygen in a bottle, how do they mix? I know that it wouldn't turn into water unless lit on fire. If the bottle was turned upside down and uncapped, would the oxygen fall out the bottom and hydrogen float to the top? Or are the two molecules stuck together so that both would end up falling out?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Ambient conditions? Google "entropy of mixing."
 
tackyattack said:
So I'm curious, if you mix two parts hydrogen and one part oxygen in a bottle, how do they mix?
They mix by diffusion. So, when you start out, they are essentially completely intermixed (provided you've waited long enough).
I know that it wouldn't turn into water unless lit on fire. If the bottle was turned upside down and uncapped, would the oxygen fall out the bottom and hydrogen float to the top? Or are the two molecules stuck together so that both would end up falling out?
First, what do you think would happen if you turned it upside down and it wasn't uncapped?
 
Chestermiller said:
First, what do you think would happen if you turned it upside down and it wasn't uncapped?

I'm not sure. If it was lighter than air, it would float to the top. If it were heavier, it'd sink to the bottom?
 
tackyattack said:
I'm not sure. If it was lighter than air, it would float to the top. If it were heavier, it'd sink to the bottom?
Why doesn't it do that when the bottle is right-side-up?
 
Chestermiller said:
Why doesn't it do that when the bottle is right-side-up?

Because... Gravity...?
 
tackyattack said:
I know that it wouldn't turn into water unless lit on fire.

Not true - it takes very, very little energy to do this. Much less than can be provided by an ordinary spark due to static electricity. I've seen a balloon filled with a 2:1 mixture explode as soon as it touched the ceiling.

When you think about Chestermiller's question - how does the gas know whether the bottle is right side up or upside down?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Chestermiller

Similar threads

Back
Top