How do we technically define emotion in singing?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Skhandelwal
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Emotion
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the concept of emotion in singing, highlighting the distinction between technical skill and emotional expression. It is noted that some singers may have strong technical abilities but lack emotional depth, while others may sing poorly yet convey significant emotion, which resonates with listeners. The conversation questions the ability to precisely define "emotion in singing," suggesting that human perception is inherently imprecise and influenced by individual triggers. It is argued that emotional expression in music may stem from exaggerations in pitch and tempo, and that music itself does not carry emotion; rather, it is the listener's response that evokes feelings. Examples of various artists illustrate that technical proficiency does not always equate to emotional impact, with some singers achieving fame despite unconventional vocal qualities, while others, despite technical excellence, fail to connect emotionally with audiences. The discussion emphasizes the subjective nature of emotional experience in music.
Skhandelwal
Messages
400
Reaction score
3
Sometimes, people can be singing pretty good, but they don't have any emotion in the song. and sometimes, people sing pretty pathetic, but they got so much emotion in it, that we still like it. I was wondering, what is emotion in singing technically?

Am I being clear?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Why do you assume we have the conceptual tools that are precise enough to distinguish between "emotion in singing" or not?

Precision is NOT a natural characteristic about human perception, perceptive "adequacy" is what natural selection pre-occupies itself with.

Any precision level beyond that becomes progressively more difficult for us to attain.
 
Might as well ask what affect emotion has on normal speaking, because the indicators of emotion in any uttering is probably the same.

I believe they are exaggerations in pitch and tempo mostly.
 
I didn't mean to ridicule your question, but only to point out that we don't have the sufficient tools by which we may provide an answer.

We FEEL, in some vague way, when someone sings with emotion or not, and that feeling of ours might well have somewhat different triggers in different individuals.
 
Music carries no emotion. People who listen to music may or may not experience an emotion (hormonal release) that is evoked by the music they hear.
 
Skhandelwal said:
Sometimes, people can be singing pretty good, but they don't have any emotion in the song. and sometimes, people sing pretty pathetic, but they got so much emotion in it, that we still like it. I was wondering, what is emotion in singing technically?

Am I being clear?
You're being clear enough. Bob Dylan had (has) a very nasal irritating voice, but his poetry, inflection, and phrasing made him a mega-star. Neil Young's voice is nothing to write home about, but he's done very well. Axl Rose and Jon Bon Jovi sing like rusty hinges, and neither one of them can keep my attention for more than a couple of seconds. I wouldn't walk across the street to see Wayne Newton or Paul Anka for free, though, despite their vocal abilities. People like Celine Dionne and Mariah Carey leave me cold, too. Technically good, but no soul. If you want to listen to a female vocalist who is technically very proficient, and sings from her heart, get "Babes in the Woods" or "No Frontiers" by Mary Black. She doesn't write her songs, but chooses those that she connects with, and the results are fantastic.
 
Just ONCE, I wanted to see a post titled Status Update that was not a blatant, annoying spam post by a new member. So here it is. Today was a good day here in Northern Wisconsin. Fall colors are here, no mosquitos, no deer flies, and mild temperature, so my morning run was unusually nice. Only two meetings today, and both went well. The deer that was road killed just down the road two weeks ago is now fully decomposed, so no more smell. Somebody has a spike buck skull for their...
Back
Top