How negative energy solution has positive energy in lab?

mings6
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
In QFT equations, there are not only positive energy solutions, but negative ones as well.

Dirac had the hole theory. But the sea may have infinite charges and gravity effects.
And then QFT textbooks just explain the negative solution as anti-particle.

But in the lab, we measure the energies of particle and anti-particle.
Both have positive energies.

So my question is, how to explain that
anti-particle has negative energy eigen value,
but in lab observed positive energy?

If anti-matter had negative energy,
particle-antiparticle annihilation
will cancel each other's energies out
as Energy+(-Energy)=0.
But in fact we observed Energy+Energy=2 Energy(of gamma).

Thanks
 
Physics news on Phys.org
In QFT, both particles and antiparticles have positive energy. This solves the issue with Dirac's equation.
 
mings6 said:
So my question is, how to explain that anti-particle has negative energy eigen value, but in lab observed positive energy?
In the original interpretation of the Dirac equation as a single-particle wave equation, negative energy solutions did appear. Dirac's hole theory attempted to remedy this, but lasted only a year or two before it was shown to be inconsistent by Heisenberg.

In QFT, Ψ is no longer a wavefunction, it's an annihilation operator. And its negative-frequency part is reinterpreted, not as annihilating a negative energy particle but as creating a positive energy antiparticle. The Hilbert space for QFT contains no negative energy states, only positive energy particles and positive energy antiparticles.
 
Insights auto threads is broken atm, so I'm manually creating these for new Insight articles. Towards the end of the first lecture for the Qiskit Global Summer School 2025, Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Olivia Lanes (Global Lead, Content and Education IBM) stated... Source: https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/quantum-entanglement-is-a-kinematic-fact-not-a-dynamical-effect/ by @RUTA
If we release an electron around a positively charged sphere, the initial state of electron is a linear combination of Hydrogen-like states. According to quantum mechanics, evolution of time would not change this initial state because the potential is time independent. However, classically we expect the electron to collide with the sphere. So, it seems that the quantum and classics predict different behaviours!
Back
Top