How to Calculate the Absolute Uncertainty in Distance Measurement?

  • Thread starter Thread starter anwarjackson
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Uncertainty
AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on calculating the absolute uncertainty in the measurement of distance R, specifically when R is raised to the power of negative two. The initial calculation attempts to use the formula for uncertainty propagation but encounters issues with unit consistency and the application of the exponent. It is clarified that the correct formula involves using the derivative of R raised to the appropriate power, leading to the realization that the relative uncertainty was mistakenly identified as absolute uncertainty. Ultimately, the correct approach confirms that the units for R^2 and 1/R^2 are derived from the original units of R, and proper calculations yield the desired uncertainty. The conversation emphasizes the importance of consistent units and accurate application of uncertainty formulas.
anwarjackson
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
A distance R is measured to be 4.000±0.006 m. What is the absolute uncertainty in R to the power of negative two?

Here is what i tried, apparently my units are not correct, if anyone can suggest the porper units that would be much appreciated.

let x be uncertainty of R^-2,
let y be uncertainty of R
let n be raised power (in this case -2)x = n(R^n-1)y
= 2 (1/4)0.006
= 0.003

What am I doing wrong? Question was posted on the CAPA problem sets for my physics class, CAPA keeps saying improper units however I've attempted to use millimeters, centimeters, meters and even kilometers.

Therefore, uncertainty of R^-2 is 0.0625 ± 0.003 m
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
If R has units of m, then:

R^2 has units of ___?
1/R^2 has units of ___?

p.s. 0.003 would be the relative uncertainty, not the absolute uncertainty.
 
WOW, thanks I wasn't thinking of that, I've been awake for too long apparently.
 
hey how did u get (1/4)

help me

my values are (3.000+- 0.002) samw ques capa
 
Welcome to Physics Forums. What do you know about calculating uncertainties?
 
its cool man i got the ans after like 2mint i posted the thing...i did it in my own method..same result thanks anyways
 
You had the formula right, and the units don't quite matter, as long as you're using the same units for R and \Delta R when you plug them into your formula.

Your formula is correct too, only you plugged in n=-2 in one place, and n=0 in the other!

x=nR^(n-1) y
Plugging in n=-2, and ignoring the negative sign we get for x, since it is an uncertainty:
x=2R^(-3) y
4^-3 is not 1/4.
 
Back
Top