How to figure the voltage drop at different points along a circuit?

  • Thread starter Thread starter alan2023
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Voltage drop
Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around calculating voltage drop at various points along a circuit with multiple loads positioned at different distances from the power source. Participants explore mathematical approaches to determine voltage drop, considering factors such as wire resistance and load characteristics. The conversation includes both theoretical and practical aspects of electrical circuit analysis.

Discussion Character

  • Technical explanation
  • Mathematical reasoning
  • Debate/contested

Main Points Raised

  • One participant proposes a formula for calculating voltage drop for a single load and questions how to adapt it for multiple loads at varying distances.
  • Another participant suggests that the complexity of the calculation increases with constant-power loads, which can affect voltage drop significantly.
  • Some participants mention the need to consider upstream loads when calculating voltage drop at a specific load point.
  • There are suggestions to use simultaneous equations or circuit simulation software (like SPICE) to solve for voltage drop in more complex scenarios.
  • One participant provides a detailed table of circuit parameters and voltage drops for various distances, indicating a method of calculating voltage drop for each load separately.
  • Another participant questions the method of summing voltage drops from the table, suggesting a different approach based on wire resistivity.
  • Participants discuss different methods of calculating voltage drop, including the 2KIL/CM method and its relation to resistivity.
  • There is mention of the importance of drawing the circuit and including wire resistance to accurately analyze voltage drop across multiple loads.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the methods for calculating voltage drop, with no consensus on a single approach. Some agree on the need for circuit analysis while others propose different mathematical techniques. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the best method to apply in complex scenarios.

Contextual Notes

Participants highlight limitations in their approaches, such as the need for specific assumptions about load characteristics and wire resistivity. The discussion reflects varying levels of complexity in circuit analysis based on the arrangement of loads and distances from the source.

Who May Find This Useful

This discussion may be useful for electrical engineers, electricians, and students interested in understanding voltage drop calculations in circuits with multiple loads.

  • #31
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Baluncore
Engineering news on Phys.org
  • #32
It seems that actually it is a little more complicate.

The supply voltage is AC -as usual- and a driver AC/DC is provided in order to supply DC. Then 350 mA it could be the DC output [18-42 V].Let’s say Vdc=20 V Pdc=0.35*20=7 W.

In the interval of 115 to 125 Vac the LED current is 350 mA, but the Iac current is variable from 7/115=0.06087 to 7/125=0.056 A neglecting the losses and power factor.

If we consider 0.8 as power factor and 95% as efficiency we get

S=7/0.8/0.95=9.21VA and the currents Iacmin=9.21/125=0.07368 A and 36.87 degrees

Iacmax=9.21/115=0.08 A and 36.87 degrees.
LED AC-DC Driver.jpg
 
  • #33
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #34
The Electrician said:
@alan2023, are you still around?
From their profile page:
Last seen:
Yesterday, 10:03 AM
 
  • #35
Yes, I'm still here.

Without getting into all the nitty-gritty with the inner workings of an LED driver/fixture, I believe I'm starting to understand a bit more how the loads after a point on a circuit affect the voltage drop.

Looking at this original question from an electrical install perspective, my challenge to someone would be how to build a spreadsheet to plug in the distances and any other necessary values (voltage, wire size/resistance, amps, etc.). As an electrician, I use custom calculators usually in a spreadsheet to determine voltage drop, conduit fill, cable tray fill. I first understand the code/math requirements, then build the sheet/formulas.

Wanting to add the feature of multiple loads on the same circuit, (which is something very common, and voltage drop becomes an issue in long distance applications like exterior lighting), I believe I could just build the circuits including the wire as a resistor. So basically a combo series/parallel circuit. I know there are probably some great software tools you guys use, but I believe this could built in a spreadsheet and in doing so, I have a calculator to speed up future calculations, but also understand how it works.

Thank you all for the input, and I'm sorry if sent us down a rabbit hole:biggrin:.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #36
alan2023 said:
Looking at this original question from an electrical install perspective, my challange to someone would be how to build a spreadsheet to plug in the distances and any other necessary values (voltage, wire size/resistance, amps, etc.).
An estimate of the voltage drop can be made by assuming equal loads, distributed equally along the cable.

The number of loads is, n = 13.
The current drawn by each load is, i = 0.35 A.
The length of the cable is, d = 580 ft.
The resistance per unit length is, r = 1.6 milliohm/ft.

The average current is, i * n / 2.
The return resistance per unit length is, 2 * r.
The twos will cancel.

V drop = n * i * d * r = 4.2224 volt.
V far end = 120.0000 - 4.2224 = 115.7776 V.
 
  • #37
alan2023 said:
Looking at this original question from an electrical install perspective, my challenge to someone would be how to build a spreadsheet to plug in the distances and any other necessary values (voltage, wire size/resistance, amps, etc.). As an electrician, I use custom calculators usually in a spreadsheet to determine voltage drop, conduit fill, cable tray fill. I first understand the code/math requirements, then build the sheet/formulas.
Here's how you could setup a spreadsheet using 7 columns, A,B,C,D,E,F,G. This setup assumes
a constant load current of .35 A per load.

XLoads.png


Think of the length of wiring between loads as constituting a "zone". There are 13 zones also counting the distance from the 120V feed to the first load as a zone.

Column A is the distance of each load from the 120 volt feed.
Column B is the distance between loads, including the distance from the feed to the first load.
Column C is just a reverse integer sequence starting with the number of loads.
Column D is .35 times column C (element by element). These are the currents in each zone.
Column E is .0032 (2 * the resistance per foot of the wire used; the approximate value used here is
the one given by Berkeman. For other than 12 ga, use 2 * the value for that wire) times column D.
This is the voltage drop per foot of wire in a zone.
Column F is column B times column E (element by element). At this point the elements of column F are the voltage drops within each zone; they are the decrease in voltage from one load to the next.

Column G is the voltage at each load. Creating column G requires the use of a procedure. Start with 120V and subtract the first element of column F; this becomes the first element of column G. Now subtract the second element of column F from the just calculated first element of column G and this will be the second element of column G. Then subtract the third element of column F from the second element of column G and this will be the third element of column G. Continue this to the end.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: alan2023
  • #38
The Electrician said:
Here's how you could setup a spreadsheet using 7 columns, A,B,C,D,E,F,G. This setup assumes
a constant load current of .35 A per load.

View attachment 331825

Think of the length of wiring between loads as constituting a "zone". There are 13 zones also counting the distance from the 120V feed to the first load as a zone.

Column A is the distance of each load from the 120 volt feed.
Column B is the distance between loads, including the distance from the feed to the first load.
Column C is just a reverse integer sequence starting with the number of loads.
Column D is .35 times column C (element by element). These are the currents in each zone.
Column E is .0032 (2 * the resistance per foot of the wire used; the approximate value used here is
the one given by Berkeman. For other than 12 ga, use 2 * the value for that wire) times column D.
This is the voltage drop per foot of wire in a zone.
Column F is column B times column E (element by element). At this point the elements of column F are the voltage drops within each zone; they are the decrease in voltage from one load to the next.

Column G is the voltage at each load. Creating column G requires the use of a procedure. Start with 120V and subtract the first element of column F; this becomes the first element of column G. Now subtract the second element of column F from the just calculated first element of column G and this will be the second element of column G. Then subtract the third element of column F from the second element of column G and this will be the third element of column G. Continue this to the end.
What application is that in the snip?
 
  • #39
It's just a math app that I used to format the data in columns, but I didn't do the calculations with it; I did the actual calculations on my HP50g calculator. I don't have Excel on my computer so I couldn't actually give an example of the calculations done in Excel, but I wanted to show what it probably would look like in Excel.
 

Similar threads

Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 14 ·
Replies
14
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 22 ·
Replies
22
Views
5K
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • · Replies 28 ·
Replies
28
Views
15K
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K