How to know whether a given process is reversible?

AI Thread Summary
Reversibility in thermodynamic processes is discussed, highlighting that adiabatic processes can be considered reversible under ideal conditions, while isothermal processes often are not. The discussion emphasizes that reversibility is an idealized concept, with real processes typically being irreversible. To determine if a process is reversible, checking the entropy change of the system is suggested as a primary method, although experimental verification of equilibrium at infinitesimal intervals is noted as challenging. The conversation also touches on the physical characteristics differentiating reversible and irreversible processes, including the effects of viscosity on gas behavior during rapid deformations. Overall, understanding the relationship between entropy and process characteristics is crucial in thermodynamics.
Pushoam
Messages
961
Reaction score
53

Homework Statement


How do we know that an adiabatic process is reversible , while isothermal process is not?
Do we have to calculate the entropy change of the process or we have to check experimentally whether the system is in eqbm at infinitesimal time interval( but this seems impossible)?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

 
Physics news on Phys.org
Pushoam said:
How do we know that an adiabatic process is reversible , while isothermal process is not?
Why do you say that? The Carnot cycle is built up of adiabatic and isothermal steps, all reversible.

Pushoam said:
Do we have to calculate the entropy change of the process or we have to check experimentally whether the system is in eqbm at infinitesimal time interval( but this seems impossible)?
Reversibility is an idealized concept. In reality, no thermodynamic process is truly reversible, but reversibility is a good approximation for many cases. As far as I know, reversibility is most often stated, rather than inferred. In other words, we want a change to be reversible, and imagine a physical situation where that would be the case. Some processes, of course, are only irreversible.
 
Pushoam said:

Homework Statement


How do we know that an adiabatic process is reversible , while isothermal process is not?
Do we have to calculate the entropy change of the process or we have to check experimentally whether the system is in eqbm at infinitesimal time interval( but this seems impossible)?

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution

I think your real question is "what are the physical characteristics of an irreversible process compared to a reversible process?" Is that what you are asking?
 
Chestermiller said:
I think your real question is "what are the physical characteristics of an irreversible process compared to a reversible process?" Is that what you are asking?
Yes.
If I have been given a process, then how will I decide whether it is irreversible or not?
One method will be to check entropy of the isolated system.
Is there any other method?
 
Pushoam said:
Yes.
If I have been given a process, then how will I decide whether it is irreversible or not?
One method will be to check entropy of the isolated system.
Is there any other method?
Ok. I will be back in a while to help you get a feel for the characteristic differences between reversible and irreversible processes. Are you familiar with spring-dashpot mechanical systems?
 
Chestermiller said:
Are you familiar with spring-dashpot mechanical systems?
I haven't heard it before.
Will you please post a picture of the system?
I may recognize it.
 
Pushoam said:
I haven't heard it before.
Will you please post a picture of the system?
I may recognize it.
Instead of using this approach to help you understand irreversible processes, I think I'll try a different approach. Are you familiar with the transport (non-equilibrium) physical properties of gases and liquids known as viscosity and thermal conductivity?
 
Sorrry for replying late, please forgive me for this.

Thank you for reminding me this.
Chestermiller said:
Are you familiar with the transport (non-equilibrium) physical properties of gases and liquids known as viscosity and thermal conductivity?
I am a little bit familiar with viscosity. We can start with this.
 
When a gas is experiencing an irreversible expansion or compression, the rate of deformation of the gas is very rapid. When this happens (i.e., the process is irreversible), the behavior of the gas does not obey the ideal gas law, which is a thermodynamic equilibrium relationship. Instead, the behavior of the gas depends on the rate at which the gas is deforming. To give you an idea how this works, a very crude approximation to the behavior of an ideal gas in a cylinder under irreversible expansion or compression conditions can be written as:
$$\frac{nRT}{V}-2\frac{\eta}{V}\frac{dV}{dt}=P_{ext}\tag{1}$$where ##\eta## is the viscosity of the gas and ##P_{ext}## is the external force per unit area applied to the gas. Note the time derivative of the gas volume in the viscosity term in the equation.

Here is an example of how this plays out. Suppose you have an adiabatic expansion or compression, so that the amount of heat added or removed is zero. From the first law of thermodynamics applied to this system, we have (in differential form):
$$nC_v\frac{dT}{dt}=-P_{ext}\frac{dV}{dt}\tag{2}$$If we combine these two equations, we obtain:
$$nC_v\frac{dT}{dt}=-nRT\frac{d\ln{V}}{dt}+2\eta V\left(\frac{d\ln{V}}{dt}\right)^2\tag{3}$$If we divide this equation by T, we obtain:
$$nC_v\frac{d\ln{T}}{dt}+nR\frac{d\ln{V}}{dt}=2\frac{\eta}{T} V\left(\frac{d\ln{V}}{dt}\right)^2\tag{4}$$
But, for an ideal gas, the left hand side of this equation is the rate of change of entropy:
$$\frac{dS}{dt}=2\frac{\eta}{T} V\left(\frac{d\ln{V}}{dt}\right)^2\tag{5}$$Note that, because the rate of change of volume is squared on the right hand side of this equation, the right hand side of this equation is positive definite (and thus does not depend on whether the gas is expanding or compressing). So, according to this equation, in an adiabatic irreversible expansion or compression of an ideal gas in a cylinder, the rate of generation of entropy is always positive, and proportional to the square of the rate of change of volume.

Like I said, this development only very crude and approximate, but it contains the key physical mechanism (viscous dissipation) responsible for the generation of entropy.
 
  • #10
Chestermiller said:
But, for an ideal gas, the left hand side of this equation is the rate of change of entropy:
Looking at eqn. 2, I think that LHS of this eqn. is ##\frac{dQ}{dT}##.
Then, only the first part of the LHS of eqn (4) is ## \frac {dS}{dT}##. Isn't it so?
 
  • #11
Pushoam said:
Looking at eqn. 2, I think that LHS of this eqn. is ##\frac{dQ}{dT}##.
For someone presently involved in trying to understand the 2nd law of thermodynamics, you seem awfully confused about how even to apply the 1st law of thermodynamics to a problem. In terms of Q, what do the words "adiabatic expansion or compression" in my post #9 mean to you? Eqn. 2 is the result of applying the 1st law of thermodynamics to our problem of adiabatic expansion or compression for an ideal gas. The left hand side represents the change in internal energy, and the right hand side represents the work done by the surroundings on the gas.
Then, only the first part of the LHS of eqn (4) is ## \frac {dS}{dT}##. Isn't it so?
No. You are aware that, in addition to temperature, entropy also varies with volume, correct?
 
Back
Top